Official Celtic poll, number 1.

Started by Gaoth Dobhair Abu, December 03, 2009, 11:24:46 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who do you want to see gone in January transfer window?

Artur Boruc
14 (25.9%)
Lee Naylor
21 (38.9%)
Gary Caldwell
18 (33.3%)
Stephen McManus
18 (33.3%)
Andreas Hinkel
4 (7.4%)
Mark Wilson
12 (22.2%)
Danny Fox
0 (0%)
Glenn Loovens
7 (13%)
Scott Brown
12 (22.2%)
Shaun Maloney
8 (14.8%)
Willo Flood
21 (38.9%)
Aidan McGeady
10 (18.5%)
Marc Crosas
8 (14.8%)
Barry Robsen
6 (11.1%)
Koki Mizuno
14 (25.9%)
Giorgios Samaras
17 (31.5%)
Scott McDonald
15 (27.8%)
Cillian Sheridan
14 (25.9%)
Marc Antoine Fortune
15 (27.8%)
Paddy McCourt
9 (16.7%)

Total Members Voted: 54

Gaoth Dobhair Abu

Right lads and lasses, I had to set up a new poll outside of the Celtic thread because I want to give everyone 6 votes.
Tony Mowbray needs to have a serious spring clean in the New Year, so I wanteed to see your choices on who should be sold or just shown the door.
Happy to see everyones opinions, not just the Celtic minded on the board.

Hail Hail.
Tbc....

sammymaguire

DRIVE THAT BALL ON!!

Gaoth Dobhair Abu

Would wonder more why 3 people have voted for Aidan McGeady?!!!
Tbc....

The Real Laoislad

Sell them all and replace them with players from the 3rd tier of the English league,there wouldn't be much difference in skill level and the wage bill would be much lower
You'll Never Walk Alone.

Gaoth Dobhair Abu

Quote from: The Real Laoislad on December 03, 2009, 01:17:51 PM
Sell them all and replace them with players from the 3rd tier of the English league,there wouldn't be much difference in skill level and the wage bill would be much lower

Right we all get it, you don't like or rate Celtic or the SPL.  ::)
Tbc....

rossie mad


Give it a rest laois lad if its supported by a section of contributors whats the problem?



I voted wilson,naylor,robson,samaras,mcdonald,caldwell,

Voted mcdonald cause in all reality mowbray isnt going to get rid of fortune in january plus skippy seems to be unsettled.

Lawrence of Knockbride

I voted for Boruc, Brown and McManus.
Boruc as he's probably get much needed money in. Brown similarly might fetch a bit and he's so overrated it's unbelievable and McManus cos he is very poor IMO. I'd leave Naylor as although he's not great, left backs are in short supply and he can provide cover down the left side.

Gaoth Dobhair Abu

I voted Naylor, Caldwell, Brown, Wilson, Flood and Skippy.

Naylor - Bombscare
Caldwell - Over inflated sense of self worth, when in fact he seems to be getting worse as a player.
Wilson - Never has fufilled early promise.
Brown - Just not interested in playing for Celtic.
Flood - Is he still with the squad!
Skippy - Seems to have just lost his touch.
Tbc....

Main Street

The problem is who to cut out to keep it to 6.



Gaoth Dobhair Abu

Quote from: Main Street on December 03, 2009, 02:37:15 PM
The problem is who to cut out to keep it to 6.

:D :D thought that myself when I started going through the defense! Should have made it 10 picks.
Tbc....

the colonel

Get rid-

Wilson
Mizuno
Flood
McManus
Sheridan

would keep the rest because we are not likely get rid of more than 4 players. Would give the strikers to end of season but would like a few first teamers in january.

Then I'd re-evaulate the whole squad in summer
the difference between success and failure is energy

lynchbhoy

Quote from: The Real Laoislad on December 03, 2009, 01:17:51 PM
Sell them all and replace them with players from the 3rd tier of the English league,there wouldn't be much difference in skill level and the wage bill would be much lower
:D
and they are still as 'good' as liverpool right now !!


I voted caldwell , wilson and maloney for jan - just so Mowbray isnt temted to pick them - a few more to go then in the summer !!
..........

The Real Laoislad

Quote from: lynchbhoy on December 03, 2009, 03:20:48 PM
Quote from: The Real Laoislad on December 03, 2009, 01:17:51 PM
Sell them all and replace them with players from the 3rd tier of the English league,there wouldn't be much difference in skill level and the wage bill would be much lower
:D
and they are still as 'good' as liverpool right now !!




No their not Liverpool are still in the Europa League!! :P :-[
You'll Never Walk Alone.

Gaoth Dobhair Abu

Also wouldn't be too sorry to see the back of Maloney, McManus and Sammy the Greek.
Tbc....

bingobus

Quote from: Gaoth Dobhair Abu on December 03, 2009, 02:11:01 PM
I voted Naylor, Caldwell, Brown, Wilson, Flood and Skippy.

Naylor - Bombscare
Caldwell - Over inflated sense of self worth, when in fact he seems to be getting worse as a player.
Wilson - Never has fufilled early promise.
Brown - Just not interested in playing for Celtic.Flood - Is he still with the squad!
Skippy - Seems to have just lost his touch.

Whats the story there? Happy with the money but a Hibs man or eyeing the EPL?