Messages

Rian stil cant tackle.

Quick thought,  does the team who fouls and hurts a player benefit under the new rules as in the player who was hurt has to go off for treatment and their team are down 1 player in the interim?

Have said this a few times, there's no benefit to the team that loses a player in that moment and it will mean more players will get up and play on without treatment when they need it

Spot on. A player does a hard challenge and picks up a yellow while the opposition goes down to 14 men for a few minutes. Almost worth a few yellows towards the end of a game

Down and Armagh doing their absolute best to ensure people find better things to do - or just about anything else to do - than watch Gaelic Football.

Our sport is fucked beyond words.

Wouldnt say that. Counties now simply hire too many games who are shite and who focus far too much on defense rather that attack.

Armagh county board are mad to be paying mcgeary for 10 years

They would be if that's who they were paying

Lol my bad, silly typo. Although to be fair it would have the same effect, 3 points in 36 minutes

Down and Armagh doing their absolute best to ensure people find better things to do - or just about anything else to do - than watch Gaelic Football.

Our sport is fucked beyond words.

Wouldnt say that. Counties now simply hire too many games who are shite and who focus far too much on defense rather that attack.

Armagh county board are mad to be paying mcgeary for 10 years

Rian stil cant tackle.

Quick thought,  does the team who fouls and hurts a player benefit under the new rules as in the player who was hurt has to go off for treatment and their team are down 1 player in the interim?

Anyone know where I could watch the down v Armagh game in Manchester?

Get the bbc app and download a VPN

Some people are really showing off! 

Some people can't understand simple instructions.

Yes i understood the original instruction. Sincere apologies for cutting to the chase. It would be far quicker just saying how many countries people have visited rather than having a 100 page thread to get to the answer

Some people are really showing off! 

Lol well the question was asked. Just to clarify thats out of all the countries not just the A &B lol

21 countries

[deliberately interfere with a player after they have played the ball away.]

Another example of Tyrone being refereed differently again. How can one be a yellow card and the other black?

Did you see the whole incident or just what we seen on the telly?

To be fair the BBC could not find why there was 1 black and 1 yellow appeared bizzarre, a big call that impacted on the game. Do you know why?

I only seen what the telly showed, as did most? My thinking is the the Tyrone man pulled him to the ground and what we seen was the grabbing each about on TV

Is that a black card?

In this case the black card should have been to the cavan player. You see Paudie on his hands and knees with the cavan player standingover him preventing him from getting up. Thats a black card for impending a player. Paudie then struggles to get up and when he does he drags him down.

Both were at it and both deserved a yellow.

You're literally making up the rules there.
To receive a black card GAA, a player must commit one of the following offences. Deliberately pull down an opponent. Intentionally trip an opponent with the foot, arm, hand, or leg. To deliberately interfere with a player after they have played the ball away.

Hampsey deliberately pulls down his opponent. This is one case where the referee has got his decision spot on to the letter of the law.

How is standing over a player stopping them from getting up not deliberately interfering with a player ? By stopping them or tripping them you are deliberately interfering with them.

It should have been 2 yellows in my opinion but if pulling a player down away from play is a black card then so should deliberately interfering with a player.

Another example of Tyrone being refereed differently again. How can one be a yellow card and the other black?

Did you see the whole incident or just what we seen on the telly?

To be fair the BBC could not find why there was 1 black and 1 yellow appeared bizzarre, a big call that impacted on the game. Do you know why?

I only seen what the telly showed, as did most? My thinking is the the Tyrone man pulled him to the ground and what we seen was the grabbing each about on TV

Is that a black card?

In this case the black card should have been to the cavan player. You see Paudie on his hands and knees with the cavan player standingover him preventing him from getting up. Thats a black card for impending a player. Paudie then struggles to get up and when he does he drags him down.

Both were at it and both deserved a yellow.

Another example of Tyrone being refereed differently again. How can one be a yellow card and the other black?

Did you see the whole incident or just what we seen on the telly?

To be fair the BBC could not find why there was 1 black and 1 yellow appeared bizzarre, a big call that impacted on the game. Do you know why?

I only seen what the telly showed, as did most? My thinking is the the Tyrone man pulled him to the ground and what we seen was the grabbing each about on TV

Someon said the cavan player threw rurari away then paudie went over to him and that started it. Not sure if thats correct though.

Who are the outstanding 23-30 year olds not on the panel at the minute? We seem very light and shorn of mature lads who are fully developed, Paul Donaghy springs immediately to mind

Rory Brennan & Mark Bradley would both add alot to that squad. Shame really.

Paudie mcnulty would be another good addition

Honest to f**k Tyrone ones are never done yapping about refs, every single game, read back through the game comments today, 90% yapping about the ref.

Bbc questioned hampsey black card questioned the high challenges, questioned the potential black card for mckerarn, questioned the time keeping. Does that sound like he had a good performance

How the hell is it a free out when 3 players are kneeing on you. Goldrick is a complete balloon

I'd go get your eyesight checked if I were you. The ref won it for you

Are you serious? 5 cavan high challenges unpunished by ref, phantom black card. 40 seconds extra played at end for cavan and the ref won it lol

How the hell is it a free out when 3 players are kneeing on you. Goldrick is a complete balloon