Messages

Firstly Rodney,I don't know Itchy and secondly you called me a liar when I said "I think you'll find it was widely reported at the time that James Reilly was one of the original six ", You said you'd show me newspaper articles to prove I was wrong,you didn't , but I showed you where it was reported that he was dropped.I honestly thought at the time that he was dropped,but then you come along call me a liar and failed to show that he wasn't dropped.
Then you assumed I was someone else(Itchy) and attack him!!! Did you ever hear the saying ass/u/me makes an ass ut of u and me.

As far I'm concerned  SJ or any other player are entitled to play where they like (club or county) as long as its within the rules of the GAA,but I still believe the main reason he left was to gain success and not "just to play football"


Also cast your mind back to this conversation 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
tommysmith

Re: Official Cavan GAA Thread
November 17, 2011, 09:34:29 AM »Sam you do know that Miller is still with Cavan and what is to say the other lads are not either.  A couple of fruit cakes on Hoganstand are causing all these rumours

rodney trotter

Re: Official Cavan GAA Thread
« Reply #10460 on: November 17, 2011, 12:52:46 PM »It was in the Celt tommy not just on hoganstand about them players being dropped..

when Tommysmith stated that Miller wasn't dropped you replied that "It was in the Celt tommy not just on hoganstand about them players being dropped.." now as I recall in both the Celt and the Hoganstand Miller was named as one of the six.

You still calling me a liar, I don't really care as I reckon I don't need to reply to you again on this subject.

OK Rodney,but that link does not say he wasn't dropped. Setanta.com also posted the following
http://edit.setanta.com/ie/Articles/2011/11/09/Andrews-culls-Cavan-squad/gnid-116982/

GAA website also posted after Andrews was shoved that James was as one of the lads he dropped

http://www.gaa.ie/gaa-news-and-videos/daily-news/2/1204121632-andrews-steps-down-as-cavan-boss/1/

The fact is as there's doubt whether Miller was dropped or not, then can we really assume that the others were also dropped . Have you spoken to all players involved and the management? because if not we're therefore relying on third hand information and everyone knows how stories grow legs and lose truth as it transfers from one person to the next.
So was Miller dropped at the time or was he not?

Posted by: rodney trotter
« on: January 18, 2013, 11:41:07 PM » Insert Quote

Quote from: s__words on January 18, 2013, 11:34:07 PM
Don't forget that there were a few other lads at the time who also 'weren't wanted' but are now on the county panel.One actually played against SJ last summer, think this tells you all you need to know about SJ's reasons for leaving.

Sheridan,Mackey,Lyng,Nesty,Cahill and Johnston were the 6 dropped by Andrews, Johnston wouldn't have played against any of them last summer. As none were on the panel.


I think you'll find it was widely reported at the time that James Reilly was one of the original six who were dropped and not Cahill.I'm only going on what was reported as I don't have any inside knowledge of what went on at the time or who was actually dropped or what they were told.

Don't forget that there were a few other lads at the time who also 'weren't wanted' but are now on the county panel.One actually played against SJ last summer, think this tells you all you need to know about SJ's reasons for leaving.

The way I see it is that the top seven teams plus the senior & intermediate champions,with the next best playing off with Div 2 winners.
If two teams within the top 7 were to win the senior & intermediate championships, the teams in 8th & 9th would play Div 1 next year with 10th place playing off with the winners of Div 2.
If two teams from outside the top 7 were to win the senior & intermediate championships then they along with the winner of the playoff between next highest placed finisher in Div 1 v Div 2 winners would make up Div 1 for 2013.

Sean Johnston hasn't committed a crime and his own personal decisions will not impact one iota on my life or any other poster or Cavan supporter for that matter and we should all bear that in mind. It's an amateur sport and the man is free to do whatever he wants and he should be free to do it without the begrudgery and spitefullness of so-called Cavan supporters.

Neither has Val Andrews or his management team committed a crime,and likewise they should be allowed to get on with their job without the begrudgery and spitefulness of the so called Cavan supporters.