Half forwards included? they're not real forwards are they?
Where is Joe Brolly's name? Eoin Bradley's name is sitting there, a fine player was Eoin but wtf has he ever won? a McKenna Cup? Joe can blow his kisses to the Tyrone mob on the back of his 2 shiny all stars, modest enough in the scheme of the all time greats but in the context of Derry football, 2 all stars is legend.
No one named Brolly in the first thread as suitable for inclusion in the list.
The Bradley brothers were suggested by someone, so they were included. Apart from removing those not falling inside the arbitrary 40 year limit (the viewing window for 98% of posters) there has been no editing of the names provided by posters in the first thread.
If you want to include Brolly in your top ten then feel free.
It is not about the achievement of other awards or medals that should determine inclusion on a top ten list but your opinion on who should be in a top ten list.