Quote from: SHEEDY on December 16, 2023, 09:52:55 PMGlad to see St Thomas win it but still think penalties is poor way to decide itLook it's a great wee debate that and I can see why people don't like penalties to decide and prefer a replay or more additional time. Personally I think it's a great way, finish on the day. The way I see it you could argue that a team that get through via a replay could come up against a team that never needed a second chance on their way to a final and beat them by bit of luck or whatever. You have your chance on the day to put a team away and if you don't you take the lotto of penalties which you still have control over. I think it's extremely fair.