All Ireland club football championships 2023/24

[CK_Redhand]

Glen should release a statement to put pressure on the CCCC and put the ball back in their court.
"We are not seeking a replay but will play one if offered. The CCCC should investigate as per GAA rules"
or something to that effect.

[An Fhairche Abu]

Why bother? Glen should appeal asap tomorrow now that they know where they stand and the two teams can get on with preparation for the replay.

[thewobbler]

Glen should release a statement to put pressure on the CCCC and put the ball back in their court.
"We are not seeking a replay but will play one if offered. The CCCC should investigate as per GAA rules"
or something to that effect.

Why?

Either they think themselves they were cheated, or they do not. Why make it someone else's responsibility to decide if you were wronged?

The mind boggles.

[CK_Redhand]

They should bother because it shouldn't be their decision in the first place. This could force the GAA to update the rules and stop passing the buck.

[seafoid]

Why bother? Glen should appeal asap tomorrow now that they know where they stand and the two teams can get on with preparation for the replay.

it would be funny if KC lost the replay given they were 2 points up when Mullin had the fake substitution.

[thewobbler]

They should bother because it shouldn't be their decision in the first place. This could force the GAA to update the rules and stop passing the buck.

What?

The rules are designed so that insofar as possible a junior B league match and an All Ireland final are regulated in the same way.

The rules cannot prescribe every possible indiscretion and an exact sanction, or else it would be 400 pages long, impossible to follow, and need continually updated every time a new weakness is explored.

Expecting authorities to jump into arbitration without a request is clinically insane.

[gallsman]

They should bother because it shouldn't be their decision in the first place. This could force the GAA to update the rules and stop passing the buck.

What?

The rules are designed so that insofar as possible a junior B league match and an All Ireland final are regulated in the same way.

The rules cannot prescribe every possible indiscretion and an exact sanction, or else it would be 400 pages long, impossible to follow, and need continually updated every time a new weakness is explored.

Expecting authorities to jump into arbitration without a request is clinically insane.

Expecting authorities to jump into arbitration without a request for the biggest club game of the year, that was nationally televised with the facts already laid bare and not open to dispute is perfectly normal. Nothing insane about that in the slightest. Pretending otherwise is willful ignorance.

[RedHand88]

Glen should let Kilmacud go on the beer and takeaways for 3 days. Then lodge the appeal at the last minute on Wednesday. Rematch on Saturday evening.

[gallsman]

I'd be very surprised if Kilmacud haven't long since stopped.

[thewobbler]

They should bother because it shouldn't be their decision in the first place. This could force the GAA to update the rules and stop passing the buck.

What?

The rules are designed so that insofar as possible a junior B league match and an All Ireland final are regulated in the same way.

The rules cannot prescribe every possible indiscretion and an exact sanction, or else it would be 400 pages long, impossible to follow, and need continually updated every time a new weakness is explored.

Expecting authorities to jump into arbitration without a request is clinically insane.

Expecting authorities to jump into arbitration without a request for the biggest club game of the year, that was nationally televised with the facts already laid bare and not open to dispute is perfectly normal. Nothing insane about that in the slightest. Pretending otherwise is willful ignorance.

Do we honestly not know by now? In the GAA, the single most sure fire way to ensure a wrong is not corrected, is for a competition committee to hastily intervene and take liberties with the rule book. I know the rule book has a marginal opening for CCC to investigate incidents without being prompted. But really, to do so opens up an avenue of bias.

Those who are demanding the GAA intervene basically want in-game rules to be followed, but disciplinary processes in the same rule book to be ignored.

It's daft.

[Wildweasel74]

The GAA as usual show no balls, bit like all the guys getting off their red cards and don't bother to remedy the rule book. Here the decision should be made by the Gaa not either team. I hold out and if no come bck from the, GAA put in a objection at 3pm on Wednesday. Same shit show happens in the All- Ireland hurling final years ago (1998) with Offaly and Clare +, where the GAA were going to do f**k all until Clare offered a replay under pressure. Got beat well 2nd day round after been on top in the first game.

[gallsman]

Jimmy Cooney!

[downtothecore]

Any decision on this balls up should be made by the Gaa.

[trailer]

I think we're hours away from "calling in the army"

[Armagh18]

This indecision and uncertainty totally unfair on both teams who've put mammoth effort in for years in getting to this position. Needs resolved asap.