In a series of five games who would win more- Dublin or the pick of Ulster- ie Beggan, Harte, Hampsey, Murphy, Paddy McB, No-one from Derry, etc
unless the ulster team train together for a long time, dublin would win all of them
God, I don't think so- Ulster would win that with 8 weeks prep I would say. Imagine the strongest team.
During the early 1960s there was an annual game between the All Ireland champions and a Rest of Ireland selection. As far as I know the All Ireland champions usually won.
What do you mean no-one from Derry etc,Chrissy McKaigue is one of the best backs in Ireland and is every bit as good as any of the elite Dublin backs.
An Ulster Select would beat Dublin in 100 games out of 100.
You're talking about the Cream of Tyrone,Monaghan and Donegal,3 of the top 6/8 sides in the country for a start and each of the other 6 teams has outstanding players aswell.
Dublin are a fantastic team,undoubtedly one of the best ever, but the hype is getting ridiculous.
Yes
Ulster says no.
Quote from: BallyhaiseMan on September 03, 2018, 04:52:17 PM
What do you mean no-one from Derry etc,Chrissy McKaigue is one of the best backs in Ireland and is every bit as good as any of the elite Dublin backs.
An Ulster Select would beat Dublin in 100 games out of 100.
You're talking about the Cream of Tyrone,Monaghan and Donegal,3 of the top 6/8 sides in the country for a start and each of the other 6 teams has outstanding players aswell.
Dublin are a fantastic team,undoubtedly one of the best ever, but the hype is getting ridiculous.
I know, that's why I am asking if Dublin could beat Ulster as opposed to the other way around.
Quote from: Under Lights on September 03, 2018, 04:59:10 PM
Quote from: BallyhaiseMan on September 03, 2018, 04:52:17 PM
What do you mean no-one from Derry etc,Chrissy McKaigue is one of the best backs in Ireland and is every bit as good as any of the elite Dublin backs.
An Ulster Select would beat Dublin in 100 games out of 100.
You're talking about the Cream of Tyrone,Monaghan and Donegal,3 of the top 6/8 sides in the country for a start and each of the other 6 teams has outstanding players aswell.
Dublin are a fantastic team,undoubtedly one of the best ever, but the hype is getting ridiculous.
I know, that's why I am asking if Dublin could beat Ulster as opposed to the other way around.
Apologies then,if you thought i was attacking you, picked it up wrong.
BHMan McKaigue wouldn't even make their team. Excellent as he is he's not at that level.
The other 31 counties would be lucky to beat Dublin never mind just 9.
A scratch Ulster team wouldn't have a prayer against the Dubs. Maybe if they trained together for a couple of years they might have a chance.
Dublin would win handy.
The Ulster panel would all have to get jobs and live within a few miles of each other.
Would need to train together for a year and then play in the NFL.
Or the 31 other Counties could bring a Motion to Congress requiring Dublin to field 4 teams in the SFC based on the 4 Local Authority areas.
Would there be any McGourtys playing?
If Lane or Dublin Joe were refereeing Dublin would win them all
Dublin would beat the pick of the whole country never mind Ulster.
Quote from: thejuice on September 03, 2018, 07:02:26 PM
Dublin would beat the pick of the whole country never mind Ulster.
They mightn't beat a Mayo engine plus scoring forwards like Paddy McBrearty, McManus, Shane Walsh etc
At least counties outside Leinster have a chance of winning some silverware. 11 countries in Leinster ( 1/3 of the Championship ) have no chance of wining anything. Maybe win a first round championship game with the dubious prize of the Dublin monster(s) tramping them into the ground after that.
There's my team to play them lol 1.R Beggan, 2. P Hampsey. 3. N McGee 4.K Higgins, 5 K O'Connell . 6 D Hughes. 7.L Keegan, 8. A O'Shea 9.D Flynn 10. McHugh 11.M Murphy. 12. S Walsh 13. D Clifford. 14.P McBearty 15. C McManus
Quote from: Wildweasel74 on September 03, 2018, 08:29:01 PM
There's my team to play them lol 1.R Beggan, 2. P Hampsey. 3. N McGee 4.K Higgins, 5 K O'Connell . 6 D Hughes. 7.L Keegan, 8. A O'Shea 9.D Flynn 10. McHugh 11.M Murphy. 12. S Walsh 13. D Clifford. 14.P McBearty 15. C McManus
lot of them lads not from Ulster
Man above said the whole country, and couldn't get a good 15 from Ulster to give them a game
From ulster
Beggan Eoin ban Gallagher hampsey drew wylie oconnell mckaigue harte Darren Hughes Mattie donnelly McFaul macniallus Sludden mcbrearty Murphy McManus subs brendan rogers killian clarke tiarnan mccann mcvitie mark Bradley Rory grugan eoin Donnelly
Such utter crap talk...why discuss something that can never happen.
Tyrone plus Beggan and 2 good forwards e.g. McManus and McBrearty would beat Dublin.
Plus three half-backs and a midfield.
Quote from: illdecide on September 03, 2018, 10:09:37 PM
Such utter crap talk...why discuss something that can never happen.
Enough about your sex life we chatting ball here
Clarke
Barrett
Higgins
Harrison
Keegan
Boyle
Durcan
Parsons
A O'Shea
D O'Connor
R McHugh
K McLoughlin
C O'Connor
P Geaney
D Clifford
That would do it.
Mayo oh so close.