NFL Division 1 2024

[Duine Inteacht Eile]

Roscommon black card - correct call
Tyrone red card - incorrect call
Roscommon square ball - incorrect call

Both teams very good at pretending to be injured when there was nothing wrong with them. 

I actually thought black card was correct and the yellow leading to red was correct too. It was a high tackle.
Was never a square ball.
Poor enough game.
Tyrone will be happy with the young lads and the points.
Roscommon might be happy given how close they were without so many players, but they didn't play well.

Don't be confused.
It was a straight red.
The yellow was for someone else.

[SouthOfThe Bann]

It's amazing how different counties produce different player types.

For example Mayo produce unbelievable powerful runners but haven't produced a real classy forward since McDonald... Moran O'Connor O'Donoghue Conroy all decent but you wouldn't call them classy elegant footballers... Having said that there's not many in the country.

My home county Cavan have struggled to produce that type of player also.

1. Clifford
2. McGuigan
3. Shane Walsh very inconsistent though.
4. Dara Canavan starting to show signs
5. Rian O'Neill when on it
6. King Con
7. Seanie O'Shea
8. Conor Mcmanus

[weareros]

Roscommon black card - correct call
Tyrone red card - incorrect call
Roscommon square ball - incorrect call

Both teams very good at pretending to be injured when there was nothing wrong with them. 

Had a look at it again. Definitely the correct call.
The square ball for the final play is tight though I think it might just be one.
However, before that the ball comes in and a Roscommon player starts in the square, then runs across the square to collect the ball.
Tough one for Roscommon but officials got it right.

I don't think they did get it right. Glennon was in square but he collected ball outside square. It's not soccer. It's only a square ball in GAA when you are in square before the ball. The ball to Glennon never made it into square. He then quickly passed to Robbie Dolan who was also outside square and you can see from behind goal that Connolly was still outside square when Dolan released ball. I suspect that was the play umpires ruled a square ball, but was not correct.

But Tyrone were deserving winners. Got their scores much easier and were hungrier for dirty ball. We were poor. Did we win one Tyrone kickout with an extra man. Morgan a close man of the match to Canavan who was top class.

[Wildweasel74]

There was a point in the first half which just goes over the bar,the keeper may have got it but a Tyrone player contested the ball with him.Replay shows him well inside the square before the ball even kicked.

[marty34]

He threw it into the net never mind the square ball. It wasn't a palm or a fist. Both hands were on the ball and he threw it in

That's the way all passes across the square are finished to the net nowadays.

[tyrone08]

He threw it into the net never mind the square ball. It wasn't a palm or a fist. Both hands were on the ball and he threw it in

That's the way all passes across the square are finished to the net nowadays.

Normally its a palm into the net at head height or so, as the ball was nearly below the knee it looked like he threw it in rather than palmed it in. Square ball call was tight but as Conn got a ridiculous red card it balanced itself out

[highorlow]

Conn got a ridiculous red card it balanced itself out

If you think that's not a red card then you've had too many knocks on the head yourself. It was late, high and dangerous, he had time to pull out of it as well.

[Mikhailov]

Conn got a ridiculous red card it balanced itself out

If you think that's not a red card then you've had too many knocks on the head yourself. It was late, high and dangerous, he had time to pull out of it as well.

High or low - forget about it.

Had time to pull out if it - are you crazy? It was a big man colliding with a smaller man, albeit slightly late but there was no malice involved

But malice involved in every tackle on Darragh Canavan, all without punishment from a poor referee

As someone said earlier, they are all poor - you just hope you get one of the better poor ones!

[Duine Inteacht Eile]

Conn got a ridiculous red card it balanced itself out

If you think that's not a red card then you've had too many knocks on the head yourself. It was late, high and dangerous, he had time to pull out of it as well.

When you say it was "late". He collided with a player who had the ball in his hands. He still had the ball in his hands when he hit the ground.

[highorlow]

It was an awful effort at a tackle. I'll have to watch the replay but from what I saw earlier he didn't need to bull doze in the way he did.

[ONeill]

Enjoyed that today. Promising performances from a spread of new lads. Morgan, McKernan and Canavan had big games.

Roscommon manager spent the whole game yapping at the linesman with arms spread out. Every call. Yapping.

[tyrone08]

Conn got a ridiculous red card it balanced itself out

If you think that's not a red card then you've had too many knocks on the head yourself. It was late, high and dangerous, he had time to pull out of it as well.

When you say it was "late". He collided with a player who had the ball in his hands. He still had the ball in his hands when he hit the ground.

Exactly. It can't be a late tackle when the man has the ball in his hands. Some stupid comments about

[Milltown Row2]

Conn got a ridiculous red card it balanced itself out

If you think that's not a red card then you've had too many knocks on the head yourself. It was late, high and dangerous, he had time to pull out of it as well.

When you say it was "late". He collided with a player who had the ball in his hands. He still had the ball in his hands when he hit the ground.

Exactly. It can't be a late tackle when the man has the ball in his hands. Some stupid comments about

Did he tackle the ball?

Was it reckless?

Was it head height?

Red card for the look of astonishment after the ref blew the whistle

[Wildweasel74]

Didn't think it was a red myself but made zero effort to tackle the ball, just block the man. Square ball, the player came across the square to collect the ball before the pass. Debatable if it should been disallowed. Ball was palmed in, not thrown, some lads must be blind.

[RedHand88]

He threw it into the net never mind the square ball. It wasn't a palm or a fist. Both hands were on the ball and he threw it in

That's the way all passes across the square are finished to the net nowadays.

Normally its a palm into the net at head height or so, as the ball was nearly below the knee it looked like he threw it in rather than palmed it in. Square ball call was tight but as Conn got a ridiculous red card it balanced itself out

Two passes before the finish was a very obvious square ball though. Man receives it deep in the square with his back to goal before it's passed back out and in. It was actually two square balls if the tight one at the end of the play is illegal as well.

RTE have missed it, they're still talking about the final touch. It wasn't for that, it was for the one in the buildup. Tg4 noticed it.