McKenna Cup 2024

[Wildweasel74]

Here the problem with the gaa, is everything is appealed, everything, time they severely tighten the rulebook and bring in a thing like in rugby where certain appeals are doubled, if unsuccessful.McGuinness thinks he's a law onto himself,

[trailer]

Here the problem with the gaa, is everything is appealed, everything, time they severely tighten the rulebook and bring in a thing like in rugby where certain appeals are doubled, if unsuccessful.McGuinness thinks he's a law onto himself,

I know. They did wrong. Take your punishment.

[marty34]

For Breach of lower Age Limit:
(i)Team Penalty:
On a Proven Objection – Award of Game to Opposing Team.
On an Inquiry by the Committee-in-Charge – Forfeiture of
Game without Award to the Opposing Team.
(ii) Player: For breach in any Grade – 2 weeks Suspension.
(iii) Person(s)-in-Charge of the Team in which the
breach is committed – 8 weeks Suspension.

Jim's only grounds for appeal is that he's not the person in charge of the team, so the county secretary is looking to take the fall for this one and probably rightly so.

Would the county secretary even know who's on the panel?

[J70]

Here the problem with the gaa, is everything is appealed, everything, time they severely tighten the rulebook and bring in a thing like in rugby where certain appeals are doubled, if unsuccessful.McGuinness thinks he's a law onto himself,

I know. They did wrong. Take your punishment.

Someday, in the way distant future, that might happen.

In the meantime, the GAA rules guidelines/gentle suggestions will remain subject to all kinds of frivolous objection and naked contempt.

[the_daddy]

For Breach of lower Age Limit:
(i)Team Penalty:
On a Proven Objection – Award of Game to Opposing Team.
On an Inquiry by the Committee-in-Charge – Forfeiture of
Game without Award to the Opposing Team.
(ii) Player: For breach in any Grade – 2 weeks Suspension.
(iii) Person(s)-in-Charge of the Team in which the
breach is committed – 8 weeks Suspension.

Jim's only grounds for appeal is that he's not the person in charge of the team, so the county secretary is looking to take the fall for this one and probably rightly so.

Would the county secretary even know who's on the panel?

Considering they have to sign the teamsheets at the very minimum, I'd be surprised if they didn't

[marty34]

For Breach of lower Age Limit:
(i)Team Penalty:
On a Proven Objection – Award of Game to Opposing Team.
On an Inquiry by the Committee-in-Charge – Forfeiture of
Game without Award to the Opposing Team.
(ii) Player: For breach in any Grade – 2 weeks Suspension.
(iii) Person(s)-in-Charge of the Team in which the
breach is committed – 8 weeks Suspension.

Jim's only grounds for appeal is that he's not the person in charge of the team, so the county secretary is looking to take the fall for this one and probably rightly so.

Would the county secretary even know who's on the panel?

Considering they have to sign the teamsheets at the very minimum, I'd be surprised if they didn't

That's what I mean.  Do they even look at them in detail?

They just sign it.

[imtommygunn]

they will now 

[PMG1]

If this is appealed the competition will be put on hold pending a result and with the league starting shortly afterwards it's very unlikely it will ever be finished

[johnnycool]

If this is appealed the competition will be put on hold pending a result and with the league starting shortly afterwards it's very unlikely it will ever be finished

The appeal can only be about Jim's suspension, not the losing of the two points, that's a given as the lad wasn't 18 before the start of 2024.
Clear breach of the rules right there, no comeback from that.
Not knowing the rules shouldn't cut it.

[imtommygunn]

I think Donegal will go through regardless too. (assuming tyrone beat armagh but I imagine they will)

[Itchy]

Decent 1st half in Newry, Cavan up by 3. Both teams giving it a right go. Down have missed a good bit.

[armaghniac]

Decent game in Armagh, now Arm 1-10 Ty 1-08 after 53 mins,

[Harold Disgracey]

This ref is poor. Decent game so far, Oisin O'Neill very good for Armagh.

[armaghniac]

Armagh 1-14 Tyrone 2-10 after Armagh goalie lost sight of a high ball.

[Captain Obvious]

Any day or night you beat Tyrone is a good night.