NFL Division 1 2024

[Milltown Row2]

That Roscommon goal looked ok but disallowed.

Which part was a square ball?

The final pass

First pass looked or could have been off side too, tight margins and well done on ref taking his time to give it

[Duine Inteacht Eile]

If a late shoulder to shoulder warranted a black card in this game then  that late collision is a red card.

I'd say the officials thought it to be reckless and dangerous more than clumsy

What Ruane did is exactly in the wording of the black card rule, not some loose interpretation by this ref.

If Ruane's shoulder was determined to deliberately cynical then  imo the red card was fair game.

5.12 To deliberately collide with an opponent after that opponent has played the ball away


Square ball was tight but looked correct. Didn't show a great angle.

[marty34]

That Roscommon goal looked ok but disallowed.

Which part was a square ball?

The final pass

First pass looked or could have been off side too, tight margins and well done on ref taking his time to give it

Offside?

[square_ball]

That's a good call for the square ball.

[RedHand88]

That's a good call for the square ball.

Yep. Bang on. Its the sort of one that could have been missed.

[marty34]

Tyrone deserved the win. Played well when down to 14.

[Captain Obvious]

That's a good call for the square ball.

Thought it was a very debatable call however Tyrone deserved the win.

[tyrone08]

He threw it into the net never mind the square ball. It wasn't a palm or a fist. Both hands were on the ball and he threw it in

[Milltown Row2]

That Roscommon goal looked ok but disallowed.

Which part was a square ball?

The final pass

First pass looked or could have been off side too, tight margins and well done on ref taking his time to give it

Offside?

Was flicking between the soccer and bog ball 

Square ball

[Milltown Row2]

He threw it into the net never mind the square ball. It wasn't a palm or a fist. Both hands were on the ball and he threw it in

He didn't 'catch' or collect the ball to throw it

[Cunny Funt]

Good and very comfortable win for Mayo, started with a strong team and moving very well for January. Galway poor and can't have many complaints about the margin of defeat.



In the 2nd live game I thought that goal should have stood for Roscommon but would have been a robbery had they got anything out of that game.

Tyrone missing some important players and their replacements all did well (helps to have All Ireland U20 team to pick from)

Roscommon lack of strength in depth without Enda Smith,Harney and Brigids players etc showed today.

[seafoid]

This is pretty pathetic from Roscommon so far. Extra man and offering absolutely nothing.

Roscommon struggling with the second album but it's only the League

[Hound]

Roscommon black card - correct call
Tyrone red card - incorrect call
Roscommon square ball - incorrect call

Both teams very good at pretending to be injured when there was nothing wrong with them. 

[Duine Inteacht Eile]

Roscommon black card - correct call
Tyrone red card - incorrect call
Roscommon square ball - incorrect call

Both teams very good at pretending to be injured when there was nothing wrong with them. 

Had a look at it again. Definitely the correct call.
The square ball for the final play is tight though I think it might just be one.
However, before that the ball comes in and a Roscommon player starts in the square, then runs across the square to collect the ball.
Tough one for Roscommon but officials got it right.

[tbrick18]

Roscommon black card - correct call
Tyrone red card - incorrect call
Roscommon square ball - incorrect call

Both teams very good at pretending to be injured when there was nothing wrong with them. 

I actually thought black card was correct and the yellow leading to red was correct too. It was a high tackle.
Was never a square ball.
Poor enough game.
Tyrone will be happy with the young lads and the points.
Roscommon might be happy given how close they were without so many players, but they didn't play well.