Football All Stars 2019

[blast05]

Current odds with PP would say this is the team:

Cluxton
T O'Sullivan McCaffrey Durcan
McCarthy Fitzsimons Cooper/Boyle
Fenton Moran
McShane Clifford Callaghan
O'Brien Mannion Murphy

Dublin 7.5, Kerry 4, Mayo 1.5, Tyrone 1, Donegal 1

Obviously those odds will change after the replay but the ones in bold are nailed on imo. If Murphy misses out in the forwards, I presume McHugh or McMenamin (14/1) would get one for Donegal instead.

Durcan in the corner despite putting in his performances at wing forward!
I can't for the life of me see how Cooper could be a 50/50 with Boyler.... but money talks i guess!

[tonto1888]

Current odds with PP would say this is the team:

Cluxton
T O'Sullivan McCaffrey Durcan
McCarthy Fitzsimons Cooper/Boyle
Fenton Moran
McShane Clifford Callaghan
O'Brien Mannion Murphy

Dublin 7.5, Kerry 4, Mayo 1.5, Tyrone 1, Donegal 1

Obviously those odds will change after the replay but the ones in bold are nailed on imo. If Murphy misses out in the forwards, I presume McHugh or McMenamin (14/1) would get one for Donegal instead.

Durcan in the corner despite putting in his performances at wing forward!
I can't for the life of me see how Cooper  could be a 50/50 with Boyler.... but money talks i guess!

It looks like the fullback and half back lines are the wrong way round in that. Same with the forwards

[Ball Hopper]

Serious competition among the forwards. 

Tyrone full forward loses out, but the full back gets in as a semi-final team must get one All Star?

McShane deserves one for sure.

No doubt McShane deserves one...but it is a crowded field of forwards all the same.

[Cunny Funt]

Current odds with PP would say this is the team:

Cluxton
T O'Sullivan McCaffrey Durcan
McCarthy Fitzsimons Cooper/Boyle
Fenton Moran
McShane Clifford Callaghan
O'Brien Mannion Murphy

Dublin 7.5, Kerry 4, Mayo 1.5, Tyrone 1, Donegal 1

Obviously those odds will change after the replay but the ones in bold are nailed on imo. If Murphy misses out in the forwards, I presume McHugh or McMenamin (14/1) would get one for Donegal instead.

Sean O'Shea and Dean Rock have done their chances no harm with both scoring 0-10 in the final last Sunday, as said already Murphy is one forward that could miss out now.  Cooper has damaged his chance and more so if Jim Gavin decides to drop him for the replay.

[BennyCake]

At the minute, I'd say it's...

Murphy, S O'Shea, Mannion
Clifford, McShane, Rock

[oliverkelly]

At the minute, I'd say it's...

Murphy, S O'Shea, Mannion
Clifford, McShane, Rock

Having Murphy and Rock in ahead of O'Brien is madness

[Blowitupref]

SOS deserves one after Sunday. Was best player in the league this year and had a decent championship up until Sunday where he was exceptional.

He probably does. Between league and championship he's scored 2-98 that works out at 7 points per game. Not bad going for a player that is still only 21.

[macdanger2]

Current odds with PP would say this is the team:

Cluxton
T O'Sullivan McCaffrey Durcan
McCarthy Fitzsimons Cooper/Boyle
Fenton Moran
McShane Clifford Callaghan
O'Brien Mannion Murphy

Dublin 7.5, Kerry 4, Mayo 1.5, Tyrone 1, Donegal 1

Obviously those odds will change after the replay but the ones in bold are nailed on imo. If Murphy misses out in the forwards, I presume McHugh or McMenamin (14/1) would get one for Donegal instead.

Durcan in the corner despite putting in his performances at wing forward!
I can't for the life of me see how Cooper  could be a 50/50 with Boyler.... but money talks i guess!

It looks like the fullback and half back lines are the wrong way round in that. Same with the forwards

I put them up in order of increasing odds rather than positions. I think it's just 6 backs and 6 forwards now rather full and half lines

[MC]

All Stars always seems too coloured by which teams get to the final.

Probably need a better system of analysis - the Fink Tank and others used to do a soccer appraisal on players based on an analysis of every meaningful contribution they made over the course of the season.

The current All Stars selection punishes good players from the weaker counties!

[BennyCake]

At the minute, I'd say it's...

Murphy, S O'Shea, Mannion
Clifford, McShane, Rock

Having Murphy and Rock in ahead of O'Brien is madness

I didn't say I'd have them! 

[J70]

At the minute, I'd say it's...

Murphy, S O'Shea, Mannion
Clifford, McShane, Rock

Having Murphy and Rock in ahead of O'Brien is madness

Madness?? Hardly.

Debatable, yes, as is any selection.

[Armagh18]

At the minute, I'd say it's...

Murphy, S O'Shea, Mannion
Clifford, McShane, Rock

Con O'Callaghan ahead of Mannion for me, but O'Brien ahead of either. Would say a big replay from either if the first two and they'd pip Murphy.

[imtommygunn]

I would say ahead of rock. Rock hasn't played for half the year.

O'Callaghan may not have been quite as good last day but Kerry were panicking every time he got the ball and on another day I think he would have had a few goals.i would still expect big things from him in the replay.

[yellowcard]

Current odds with PP would say this is the team:

Cluxton
T O'Sullivan McCaffrey Durcan
McCarthy Fitzsimons Cooper/Boyle
Fenton Moran
McShane Clifford Callaghan
O'Brien Mannion Murphy

Dublin 7.5, Kerry 4, Mayo 1.5, Tyrone 1, Donegal 1

Obviously those odds will change after the replay but the ones in bold are nailed on imo. If Murphy misses out in the forwards, I presume McHugh or McMenamin (14/1) would get one for Donegal instead.

Don't understand Cooper odds at all. Has missed a large part of the season through injury, is already past his best, was in all sorts of difficulty before getting sent off on Sunday. If he hadn't already credit built up from previous seasons he would be dropped from the Dublin team for the replay.

[macdanger2]

Current odds with PP would say this is the team:

Cluxton
T O'Sullivan McCaffrey Durcan
McCarthy Fitzsimons Cooper/Boyle
Fenton Moran
McShane Clifford Callaghan
O'Brien Mannion Murphy

Dublin 7.5, Kerry 4, Mayo 1.5, Tyrone 1, Donegal 1

Obviously those odds will change after the replay but the ones in bold are nailed on imo. If Murphy misses out in the forwards, I presume McHugh or McMenamin (14/1) would get one for Donegal instead.

Don't understand Cooper odds at all. Has missed a large part of the season through injury, is already past his best, was in all sorts of difficulty before getting sent off on Sunday. If he hadn't already credit built up from previous seasons he would be dropped from the Dublin team for the replay.

Yeah, Cooper is definitely the outlier in that bunch