All Stars 2022

Started by ONeill, July 09, 2022, 11:19:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

seafoid

It will also depend on competition in each position and across forwards, midfield and backs.
"f**k it, just score"- Donaghy   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IbxG2WwVRjU

seafoid

It would probably be more interesting to make a group stab at the 45 nominees to see where the gaps in quality are.
Last year nominations per county were

Tyrone 15
Mayo 8
Kerry 7
Dublin 5
35 from the semifinalists
Monaghan 3
Armagh 2
Clare, Cork, Donegal, Galway and Kildare  1 each
"f**k it, just score"- Donaghy   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IbxG2WwVRjU

The Trap

Pretty sure we will see a team announced from 2000 to 2022 just like the hurling so here is a first stab at that:
Cluxton
Marc OSe
Moynihan
Higgins
Mccarthy
McGeeney
McCaffrey
Fenton
Cavanagh
Connolly
Cooper
Kilkenny
Clifford
Con
Canavan

Some I couldn't get in
Dara and tomas Ose
Michael Murphy
Declan OSullivan
Ricey
Philip Jordan
Stephen. ONeill
Mcmahon and Cooper
Paul Flynn
James Odonoghue
Karl Lacey
Brian McGuigan


Estimator

Oisin McConville's team of the year:

Shane Ryan (Kerry)

Chrissy McKaigue (Derry)
Seán Kelly (Galway)
Tom O'Sullivan (Kerry)

James McCarthy (Dublin)
John Daly (Galway)
Gavin White (Kerry)

Cillian McDaid (Galway)
Rian O'Neill (Armagh)

Shane McGuigan (Derry)
Seán O'Shea (Kerry)
Ciarán Kilkenny (Dublin)

David Clifford (Kerry)
Damien Comer (Galway)
Shane Walsh (Galway)
Ulster League Champions 2009

thewobbler

Quote from: The Trap on July 26, 2022, 10:32:45 PM
Pretty sure we will see a team announced from 2000 to 2022 just like the hurling so here is a first stab at that:
Cluxton
Marc OSe
Moynihan
Higgins
Mccarthy
McGeeney
McCaffrey
Fenton
Cavanagh
Connolly
Cooper
Kilkenny
Clifford
Con
Canavan

Some I couldn't get in
Dara and tomas Ose
Michael Murphy
Declan OSullivan
Ricey
Philip Jordan
Stephen. ONeill
Mcmahon and Cooper
Paul Flynn
James Odonoghue
Karl Lacey
Brian McGuigan

What did Lee Keegan do to you in a past life?

He's an automatic pick regardless of criteria. Well unless the criteria is has to have won an AI.

The Trap

Forgot about Lee keegan.....had Keith higgins in and he hadn't won an all ireland.......maybe just swap them.......loved higgins though!

trueblue1234

Gormley not get a mention? I think people forget how good he was.
Dooher another that's unlucky to make the cut. Be a tough one to tie down. Forget about other peoples opinions, ask me two days running and I'd prob give you two different answers!!
Grammar: the difference between knowing your shit

oakleaflad

Murphy would have to be in it for me. I'd give a shout for Sean Marty Lockhart too.

imtommygunn

Has O'Callaghan done enough to be included in that kind of company? Still very young. Bernard Brogan probably there or thereabouts and Murphy has to be in it IMO. Donegal be nothing without him and have an AI and really should have had another one.

shark

Quote from: imtommygunn on July 27, 2022, 09:48:24 AM
Has O'Callaghan done enough to be included in that kind of company? Still very young. Bernard Brogan probably there or thereabouts and Murphy has to be in it IMO. Donegal be nothing without him and have an AI and really should have had another one.

Cork have one in this period too , plus two more final appearances, but none of their players will be mentioned here.

2000 to 2022 is a very long period of time. And depends if we are looking at the best players, or the best players from the best teams , as there is a big difference!
If it's based off those who won all-stars in the period then John Keane with 2 all-stars should be in the conversation. But I'm sure recency bias will apply.

Redhand Santa

Without thinking much about who's missing from the list I'd have Dara O'se in for Connolly with Cavanagh moving to half forward. Murphy in for O'Callaghan.

mouview

Quote from: The Trap on July 26, 2022, 10:32:45 PM
Pretty sure we will see a team announced from 2000 to 2022 just like the hurling so here is a first stab at that:
Cluxton
Marc OSe
Moynihan
Higgins
Mccarthy
McGeeney
McCaffrey
Fenton
Cavanagh
Connolly
Cooper
Kilkenny
Clifford
Con
Canavan

Some I couldn't get in
Dara and tomas Ose
Michael Murphy
Declan OSullivan
Ricey
Philip Jordan
Stephen. ONeill
Mcmahon and Cooper
Paul Flynn
James Odonoghue
Karl Lacey
Brian McGuigan

Where's Padraig Joyce?

seafoid

There were 23 footballers of the year between 2000 and 2022.
Who would you leave out?
"f**k it, just score"- Donaghy   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IbxG2WwVRjU

tbrick18

Quote from: The Trap on July 26, 2022, 10:32:45 PM
Pretty sure we will see a team announced from 2000 to 2022 just like the hurling so here is a first stab at that:
Cluxton
Marc OSe
Moynihan
Higgins
Mccarthy
McGeeney
McCaffrey
Fenton
Cavanagh
Connolly
Cooper
Kilkenny
Clifford
Con
Canavan

Some I couldn't get in
Dara and tomas Ose
Michael Murphy
Declan OSullivan
Ricey
Philip Jordan
Stephen. ONeill
Mcmahon and Cooper
Paul Flynn
James Odonoghue
Karl Lacey
Brian McGuigan

I dont disagree with any of the players above, but with a total Derry bias applied I think all of the following would be in contention for this team:
Sean Marty Lockhart
Kevin McCloy
Kevin McGuckian
Fergal Doherty
Paddy Bradley
Enda Muldoon

Redhand Santa

Quote from: tbrick18 on July 27, 2022, 11:44:11 AM
Quote from: The Trap on July 26, 2022, 10:32:45 PM
Pretty sure we will see a team announced from 2000 to 2022 just like the hurling so here is a first stab at that:
Cluxton
Marc OSe
Moynihan
Higgins
Mccarthy
McGeeney
McCaffrey
Fenton
Cavanagh
Connolly
Cooper
Kilkenny
Clifford
Con
Canavan

Some I couldn't get in
Dara and tomas Ose
Michael Murphy
Declan OSullivan
Ricey
Philip Jordan
Stephen. ONeill
Mcmahon and Cooper
Paul Flynn
James Odonoghue
Karl Lacey
Brian McGuigan

I dont disagree with any of the players above, but with a total Derry bias applied I think all of the following would be in contention for this team:
Sean Marty Lockhart
Kevin McCloy
Kevin McGuckian
Fergal Doherty
Paddy Bradley
Enda Muldoon

Maybe Lockhart but it would be very hard to make a case for the rest of them ahead of what is currently there. Likes of McCloy would be behind a right few full backs including the likes of Fay (there at start of the period) and Hampsey.