Should An Glenn object?

[Milltown Row2]

Result will not stand, simply because in the rulebook for the infringement the penalty is conceding the game, fine, replay. One too much, the other too light a punishment. Doesn't matter who's fault it is, that what it states.

This is my first comment on this
As stated above the penalty is conceding the game, fine OR a replay
On what grounds do they decide which penalty to issue ?
I mean 3 penalties for 1 infringement
You either break the rule or you don't

I suppose it depends on the level of the offence. Maybe if Mullin had actually caught the ball or made a block on the line a forfeit would have been in order, or if it could (not sure how though) be proven that KC intentionally played with an extra man. In this case a replay is probably fair. Maybe in Mannions case a fine would be a applicable for him being away from the action but still on the field.

Are we fining all clubs that have lads standing over the line now? Wow

Yeah, this has been happening for years, at least at Ulster club level onwards.

At club level normal, not at this end, even though the same rules apply throughout

I remember getting a list as manager when we were in Ulster and then onwards to Croke, the list of things you'll get fined for is so petty, it was a money making racket, as mentioned socks up on parade, only the squad numbered on the pitch even though you had a larger squad to work with.

[seafoid]

So where's this replay everyone said was going to happen?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPo5wWmKEaI

[Armagh18]

So where's this replay everyone said was going to happen?

Meeting between Glen and KC tonight isnt there?

[seafoid]

I mo thuarim this is the best summary and how the CCCC are likely to see things. I can't see KC bringing in the culture war analysis and winning a fine.


https://www.irishtimes.com/sport/gaelic-games/2023/01/23/glen-express-disappointment-at-gaas-failure-to-review-breach-of-rules/


A rematch the likely resolution. Although Mullin had no material impact on the play that unfolded – he didn't touch the ball – there is a view that it's impossible to infer what would have happened had the correct number of players been on the field.

The calculation then is the balance of the contest, which at the time was a one-score match.

Fines have been levied previously when matches were essentially decided on the scoreboard but not when the result was still in doubt.

Referees' decisions are not disputable when it comes to match outcomes even if a mistake has been made. That was established by the DRA in the matter of Fr Casey's GAA club in Limerick back in 2005.

That does not however apply to situations like this, breach of match regulations, when the primary mistake is by the team itself in not making sure that they don't have too many players on the field.

[nrico2006]

The question going forward is do we start replaying games when there are faults made by officials? More serious ones that this happen all the time.

[tonto1888]

The question going forward is do we start replaying games when there are faults made by officials? More serious ones that this happen all the time.

The issue here is that the rule book actually covers what happened with penalties stipulated. There is nothing to say there will be penalties if a ref doesn't give a penalty when he should or sends someone off wrongly etc.

[seafoid]

The question going forward is do we start replaying games when there are faults made by officials? More serious ones that this happen all the time.

List the first 50 then

[Armagh18]

The question going forward is do we start replaying games when there are faults made by officials? More serious ones that this happen all the time.

Most will be hard to prove unless the game is taped and even at that, we could argue all day over whether someone should have been red card, a penalty should have been given etc, etc.

[shawshank]

So where's this replay everyone said was going to happen?

Don't come over yourself yet. Glen put in an appeal, KC had 3 days to object and then this evening both parties are invited to a meeting. Time

[Baile Brigín 2]

100% on the officials. The Club Champions should not be punished because the officials made a slight error on the day. Ireland didn't get a replay with France after Henry's handball.

KC get away with this without sanction, and through the GAA's wilful blindness in following their own rules, then there is absolutely no deterrent on future transgressions -- ah sure, what's the worst could happen.

It's referee error. It happens

[JoG2]

It's one meeting I wouldn't want to be involved in. We talking a couple of committee members and a couple of senior players representing each (Crokes sending 3 players) ?

[Armagh18]

It's one meeting I wouldn't want to be involved in. We talking a couple of committee members and a couple of senior players representing each (Crokes sending 3 players) ?

Wonder will they send Walsh and Mullin lol

[Hound]

Shane Walsh supposedly in Australia.

If it had finished level, was the plan for extra-time and penalties, or a replay?

[seafoid]

Appparently Mullin is going to stand at the door of the meeting room although he won't be a member of the 3 person representation.

[Milltown Row2]

Appparently Mullin is going to stand at the door of the meeting room although he won't be a member of the 3 person representation.

But the ref will blow his whistle and allow him to come on in... providing he gave the slip to the 4th official that is