Top 5 players of all time from your county

[seafoid]

I went to an ice hockey match in Switzerland recently. One element that could be transferred to the GAA was  5 home  jerseys with the names and squad numbers of 5 players  suspended above the centre circle. In GAA they could be in the stand.
They represent the 5 best ever players as chosen by the fans. What 5 would you choose for your county ?

[HokeyPokey]

Peter Canavan
Frank McGuigan
Sean Cavanagh
Iggy Jones

Last one is a tough one, possibly one of Stephen O'Neill, Eugene McKenna, Brian Dooher, Conor Gormley or Phillip Jordan.

[Silver hill]

Anthony Tohill
Sean O'Connell
Kieran Mckeever
Jim Mckeever
Fergal Doherty

[J70]

Michael Murphy
Karl Lacey
Martin McHugh
Manus Boyle
Brian McEniff (player/manager contributions combined)

[thewobbler]

Im led to believe that if you go back to the sixties then Sean O'Neill, Paddy Doherty and Tom O'Hare would all make the list. Colm McAlarney for the seventies too.

But in my time:

Greg Blaney
Mickey Linden
Benny Coulter
James McCartan Jr
Ross Carr

[befair]

Sean O'Neill
Paddy Doherty
Leo Murphy
Mickey Linden
Benny Coulter

[ONeill]

Can only go on those I've actually watched live.

Peter Canavan
Sean Cavanagh
Philip Jordan
Stephen O'Neill
Brian Dooher

Didn't see enough of Frank.

[Ghost]

Anthony Tohill
Sean O'Connell
Kieran Mckeever
Jim Mckeever
Fergal Doherty

I'm assuming you're  a bit older than me. Never seen mckeever or o connell but can't be having doherty over paddy Bradley.

[timmyot501]

Eugene "Nudie" Hughes
Conor McManus
Ciaran Murray
Ray McCarron
Rory Beggan

[Hoof Hearted]

Anthony Tohill
Sean O'Connell
Kieran Mckeever
Jim Mckeever
Fergal Doherty

I'm assuming you're  a bit older than me. Never seen mckeever or o connell but can't be having doherty over paddy Bradley.

Why ?

One of the best midfielders for most of the first 20 years of this millennium
I'm no cub either and never saw Sean or Jim play but.....

[red hander]

Peter Canavan
Frank McGuigan
Sean Cavanagh
Iggy Jones

Last one is a tough one, possibly one of Stephen O'Neill, Eugene McKenna, Brian Dooher, Conor Gormley or Phillip Jordan.

Agree with this, but would throw Brian McGuigan into mix for fifth spot.

[Saffrongael]

Antrim

Olcan McFetridge
Leonard McKeegan
Ciaran Barr
Gary O'Kane
Neil McManus

[ardtole]

Eugene "Nudie" Hughes
Conor McManus
Ciaran Murray
Ray McCarron
Rory Beggan

Tommy Freeman would be worth a mention. Always rated Vinny Corey as a great player, very consistent.

[Main Street]

Eugene "Nudie" Hughes
Conor McManus
Ciaran Murray
Ray McCarron
Rory Beggan

Tommy Freeman would be worth a mention. Always rated Vinny Corey as a great player, very consistent.

What about Rory Beggan V Paddy Linden

[Nanderson]

Eugene "Nudie" Hughes
Conor McManus
Ciaran Murray
Ray McCarron
Rory Beggan

Always thought Paul Finlay would have been held in high regard by the monaghan faithful