Greatest player never to win an all Ireland

[RoundBall]

Frank McGuigan hands down. Honourable mention to the great Iggy Jones.

[Gmac]

Has to be lots of great hurlers too  Ciaran Carey springs to mind

[Dag Dog]

Ciaran Carey all day. Gary Kirby too.

[Heshs Umpire]

 Dermot Earley Snr

[blanketattack]

Tommy Murphy and it's not even close.
In hurling, probably Ken McGrath.

[From the Bunker]

Val Daly

[Truth hurts]

Shorty Treanor.

Bennys goal scoring feats were unbelievable and he deserved one.

I would put Tommy McGovern ahead of Shorty

Shorty could have had two yet he fell out with management.

[From the Bunker]

Mjchael Meehan

[From the Bunker]

Brian Talty

[From the Bunker]

Joe Rabbitte

[From the Bunker]

Eugene Cloonan

[The Wedger]

Joe Rabbitte

No, just no!

[From the Bunker]

Ollie Canning

[From the Bunker]

Damian Hayes

[grounded]

Kevin O'Brien was a fantastic player for Wicklow and of course Baltinglass.