Standard of Refs

[RedHand88]

As a Tyrone man, I can say it wasn't Gough referred the Derry semi final.

[shawshank]

just seen that sorry, I meant to put McQuillians name into the post instead of Gough. And that was the pt, the absolute inconsistency in standards of what is a tackle or tackles resulting in cards.

[Milltown Row2]

just seen that sorry, I meant to put McQuillians name into the post instead of Gough. And that was the pt, the absolute inconsistency in standards of what is a tackle or tackles resulting in cards.

The inconsistency of people knowing who was refereeing is whats wrong here

[yellowcard]

Gough has become a bit of a celebrity referee but in fairness he did have a very good match yesterday.

[Derryman forever]

Gough has become a bit of a celebrity referee but in fairness he did have a very good match yesterday.

If you ignore the decisions he bottled.

[Silver hill]

Gough has become a bit of a celebrity referee but in fairness he did have a very good match yesterday.

If you ignore the decisions he bottled.

Which ones did he bottle?

[Derryman forever]

Gough has become a bit of a celebrity referee but in fairness he did have a very good match yesterday.

If you ignore the decisions he bottled.

Which ones did he bottle?

At least 2 second yellows on mc carthy.

[From the Bunker]

It's hard on him really. He lives and works in Dublin. The final was all about McCarthy being Captain and going for 9. Sending him off would have been a huge call.

[Milltown Row2]

It's hard on him really. He lives and works in Dublin. The final was all about McCarthy being Captain and going for 9. Sending him off would have been a huge call.

Do you think in the heat of the game with all those decisions to make, his prep going into the game he's saying "must not send off McCarthy, as he's captain and going for 9" seriously??

[Champion The Wonder Horse]

It's hard on him really. He lives and works in Dublin. The final was all about McCarthy being Captain and going for 9. Sending him off would have been a huge call.

Do you think in the heat of the game with all those decisions to make, his prep going into the game he's saying "must not send off McCarthy, as he's captain and going for 9" seriously??

Can you explain why McCarthy wasn't sent off?

[Milltown Row2]

It's hard on him really. He lives and works in Dublin. The final was all about McCarthy being Captain and going for 9. Sending him off would have been a huge call.

Do you think in the heat of the game with all those decisions to make, his prep going into the game he's saying "must not send off McCarthy, as he's captain and going for 9" seriously??

Can you explain why McCarthy wasn't sent off?

I wasn't refereeing tbf

[Champion The Wonder Horse]

It's hard on him really. He lives and works in Dublin. The final was all about McCarthy being Captain and going for 9. Sending him off would have been a huge call.

Do you think in the heat of the game with all those decisions to make, his prep going into the game he's saying "must not send off McCarthy, as he's captain and going for 9" seriously??

Can you explain why McCarthy wasn't sent off?

I wasn't refereeing tbf

If you had been, would you have sent him off?

[Milltown Row2]

It's hard on him really. He lives and works in Dublin. The final was all about McCarthy being Captain and going for 9. Sending him off would have been a huge call.

Do you think in the heat of the game with all those decisions to make, his prep going into the game he's saying "must not send off McCarthy, as he's captain and going for 9" seriously??

Can you explain why McCarthy wasn't sent off?

I wasn't refereeing tbf

If you had been, would you have sent him off?

I'd need to see them again, you can note yellow and note before sending someone off, that's Goigh's call and plenty of calls during the match from commentators saying it's good to see you having to work for a free, overall he's done a good job over the 80 minutes.

Can't get them all right, but one's thinking he's actively set out to not send someone off is flat earth style conspiracy

[Wildweasel74]

There was more than 2, he should got about 1 black and 2 yellow before he eventually carded, couldn't understand it. Book Clifford and Fitzsimmons for pulling at each other but Mccarthy clattered a no. Of players high and late and got nothing to near the end.

[Wildweasel74]

Why is it one ref makes them work for a free, and another was giving frees for very little in the semi, it's either a free or its not.