Kerry V Tyrone Fodder AISF 23rd August 2015

[never kickt a ball]

Kerry's to lose. Looks like the aristocrats will cruise to another All-Ireland title.

[Maguire01]

Whay? Because they hammered a Division 3 team?

[Syferus]

Whay? Because they hammered a Division 3 team?

D2 in fairness.

[never kickt a ball]

Whay? Because they hammered a Division 3 team?

No because they are head and shoulders better than anyone else.

[Maguire01]

Whay? Because they hammered a Division 3 team?

D2 in fairness.

Relegated.

[Syferus]

Whay? Because they hammered a Division 3 team?

D2 in fairness.

Relegated.

So then Kerry v possibly D2 Tyrone is probably cannon fodder by that measure.

Teams who got promoted or relegated are D2 or D3 depending on the point a poster wants to make.

[Maguire01]

Whay? Because they hammered a Division 3 team?

D2 in fairness.

Relegated.

So then Kerry v possibly D2 Tyrone is probably cannon fodder by that measure.

Teams who got promoted or relegated are D2 or D3 depending on the point a poster wants to make.

I'm not contemplating Kerry playing a D2 team in the semi, regardless of how you measure it. 

[yellowcard]

Kerry will beat either of Monaghan or Tyrone but I don't think you will see them roll over the way that Kildare done today.

[Captain Obvious]

Whay? Because they hammered a Division 3 team?

D2 in fairness.

Relegated.

Very poor today however Kildare aren't a division three team they will likely spend one year down there much like Monaghan two years ago.

[twohands!!!]

Whay? Because they hammered a Division 3 team?

D2 in fairness.

Relegated.

So then Kerry v possibly D2 Tyrone is probably cannon fodder by that measure.

Teams who got promoted or relegated are D2 or D3 depending on the point a poster wants to make.

It's not just posters - you often see this in some of the GAA media folk comments.

My opinion is that if a team played in Division 2 this year, in that year's championship they are still a Division 2 team as they played 7 Division 2 games as their warmup/preparation for the championship, even if they get relegated or promoted.

[ballinaman]

Confirmation that O'Donoghue dislocated his shoulder. Same shoulder that he had stabilisation surgery on after the AI last year. Very rare for it go after stabilisation surgery.
Massive impact on him for the rest of the year both physically and mentally.

[omagh_gael]

What is the timeframe for recovery?

[brokencrossbar1]

Confirmation that O'Donoghue dislocated his shoulder. Same shoulder that he had stabilisation surgery on after the AI last year. Very rare for it go after stabilisation surgery.
Massive impact on him for the rest of the year both physically and mentally.

Paul Kernan had the same problem and it ended his football career.  Pooped it twice I think after surgery.  If he's wise that will be the end of his year till he gets that shoulder back to proper working order.

[ballinaman]

What is the timeframe for recovery?

It'll require stabilisation again with a 3-4 month rehab. He'll be taped/braced for rest of season but won't be right.

[Tubberman]

Confirmation that O'Donoghue dislocated his shoulder. Same shoulder that he had stabilisation surgery on after the AI last year. Very rare for it go after stabilisation surgery.
Massive impact on him for the rest of the year both physically and mentally.

Is that the same as the most recent surgery Cillian O'Connor had on his?