Tyrone Club Football and Hurling

[Walter White]

I would have expected a black card for dragging the opponent down. Foul on a scoring opportunity is soccer?

The new rule is a goal scoring opportunity is a red card i thought

I didn't know that... but as we're copying rules from every sport.. 🤷

It definitely was a rule in championship. Tyrone conceded a penalty last year because of it with david gough

You're remembering it wrong.

It was a black card. Found the clip.

The rule apparently is a black card and a penalty not a red card.

Only applies at inter-county. Rule 5.41 Football Rules

https://www.gaa.ie/api/images/image/private/t_q-best/prd/cf3zozcuixpm7adx5pz5.pdf

[skeog]

Wonderful weekend of Club football refereed by volunteers who should be admired not vilified for their efforts.Its easy outside of the fence.

[BG_Gael]

Just noticed in the fixtures Killeeshil are down to play this Friday night in the Junior Championship Semi Final, and then are due to play the Junior Reserve Final on Sunday? Surely this can't be right?

[WT4E]

Good job Damian O'Hagan is there to identify players for Paddy Hunter...

Would love to know how much these men get paid for the coverage, half of them don't know if its pumped or stuffed.

Like a breath of fresh air when you're listening to the likes of Damian O'Hagan, Clithro or Lorcan Martin who actually know half the boys on the field of play or can actually read a game.

Don't like to criticise as they provide a great service generally and access to many more games that you wouldn't otherwise get to, but it is a bit annoying when the main commentator doesn't know many of the names and obviously isn't up to date with club football. I suppose when you're paying the amount you pay for the stream (ahem) then you should expect a certain level of service or knowledge from those doing the talking.

The commentators don't seem to get the replays of points/goals/fouls either which I don't think helps them. Even switches before the game they don't know who is or isn't on. Its probably not too difficult to work out really. At the start of the 2nd half yesterday Seamy McCallan said the Bells from Ardboe need to chip in with a few scores and one of them didn't even start.

Don't think that's correct - I heard the bowl Paddy Hunter last night thank Damian O'Hagan for commentating on a key piece of the match as 'I was watching a replay there Damian'

[Jerome]

Just noticed in the fixtures Killeeshil are down to play this Friday night in the Junior Championship Semi Final, and then are due to play the Junior Reserve Final on Sunday? Surely this can't be right?

Does this matter? Players who play on the Friday night are not eligble for the Sunday. The reserve championship should be moved forward in the calendar, maybe even during the starred games period of the season.

[WT4E]

Just noticed in the fixtures Killeeshil are down to play this Friday night in the Junior Championship Semi Final, and then are due to play the Junior Reserve Final on Sunday? Surely this can't be right?

Does this matter? Players who play on the Friday night are not eligble for the Sunday. The reserve championship should be moved forward in the calendar, maybe even during the starred games period of the season.

Shouldn't matter this way around. I remember back in 2019 when we had the best team in Ressies Junior the co board fixed the Semi Final on Friday night before the prelim round of Seniors which we where playing in on the Sunday and our opponents weren't. Our management had the option of 4 or so players who would be playing on the Sunday and then did not play them in the Ressie fixture. we got chinned by a couple of points and the lads missed out on a probable title.

[BG_Gael]

Just noticed in the fixtures Killeeshil are down to play this Friday night in the Junior Championship Semi Final, and then are due to play the Junior Reserve Final on Sunday? Surely this can't be right?

Does this matter? Players who play on the Friday night are not eligble for the Sunday. The reserve championship should be moved forward in the calendar, maybe even during the starred games period of the season.

Obviously it doesn't matter when they're just throwing it in when they fancy.

As far as I am aware they are eligible yes, goes on last year's last Championship game apparently.

[giveherlong]

Just noticed in the fixtures Killeeshil are down to play this Friday night in the Junior Championship Semi Final, and then are due to play the Junior Reserve Final on Sunday? Surely this can't be right?

Does this matter? Players who play on the Friday night are not eligble for the Sunday. The reserve championship should be moved forward in the calendar, maybe even during the starred games period of the season.

Wrong.
The players who played or came on as subs in Kileeshil last game in the 2023 Junior championship aren't eligible. Quite a few of the kileeshil team on Friday night will be available for the Reserve final on Sunday

[square_ball]

Good job Damian O'Hagan is there to identify players for Paddy Hunter...

Would love to know how much these men get paid for the coverage, half of them don't know if its pumped or stuffed.

Like a breath of fresh air when you're listening to the likes of Damian O'Hagan, Clithro or Lorcan Martin who actually know half the boys on the field of play or can actually read a game.

Don't like to criticise as they provide a great service generally and access to many more games that you wouldn't otherwise get to, but it is a bit annoying when the main commentator doesn't know many of the names and obviously isn't up to date with club football. I suppose when you're paying the amount you pay for the stream (ahem) then you should expect a certain level of service or knowledge from those doing the talking.

The commentators don't seem to get the replays of points/goals/fouls either which I don't think helps them. Even switches before the game they don't know who is or isn't on. Its probably not too difficult to work out really. At the start of the 2nd half yesterday Seamy McCallan said the Bells from Ardboe need to chip in with a few scores and one of them didn't even start.

Don't think that's correct - I heard the bowl Paddy Hunter last night thank Damian O'Hagan for commentating on a key piece of the match as 'I was watching a replay there Damian'

I dunno I have heard a few commentators say about not having a replay of an incident but maybe depends where they are if they have a screen beside them. Though it wouldn't matter how many replays Paddy has sometimes he still wouldn't know whose done what

[TabClear]

Just noticed in the fixtures Killeeshil are down to play this Friday night in the Junior Championship Semi Final, and then are due to play the Junior Reserve Final on Sunday? Surely this can't be right?

Does this matter? Players who play on the Friday night are not eligble for the Sunday. The reserve championship should be moved forward in the calendar, maybe even during the starred games period of the season.

Wrong.
The players who played or came on as subs in Kileeshil last game in the 2023 Junior championship aren't eligible. Quite a few of the kileeshil team on Friday night will be available for the Reserve final on Sunday

Does that mean that if you assume every player will drop into reserves for the last couple of seasons of their career,  they are guaranteed to have one year where they are not eligible to play Reserve Championship, even if they have dropped off senior panel? Seems a bit unfair.

[square_ball]

Does that mean that if you assume every player will drop into reserves for the last couple of seasons of their career,  they are guaranteed to have one year where they are not eligible to play Reserve Championship, even if they have dropped off senior panel? Seems a bit unfair.

Yeah it will mean that. There should be a way of tracking it that if you've played a certain number of reserve league games before the championship you should be eligible but as it stands you wouldn't be able to play as far as I know.

[Ballygawleyftw]

Will the County Board look into the Moortown vs Aghyaran brawl or was there not as much to it ?
Was hard to tell , looked like a few punches thrown anyway.

[bigtogs]

From A Clonoe perspective I can see why ref would not have gave us the free, I would have hated it to be given against us if it had of been other end of the field... but if Darragh or Ruairi was tackled like that it would be a nailed on free 100 per cent.. mattie donnelly bounced ball twice for Trillick goal it's the small things that count!

[WT4E]

Good job Damian O'Hagan is there to identify players for Paddy Hunter...

Would love to know how much these men get paid for the coverage, half of them don't know if its pumped or stuffed.

Like a breath of fresh air when you're listening to the likes of Damian O'Hagan, Clithro or Lorcan Martin who actually know half the boys on the field of play or can actually read a game.

Don't like to criticise as they provide a great service generally and access to many more games that you wouldn't otherwise get to, but it is a bit annoying when the main commentator doesn't know many of the names and obviously isn't up to date with club football. I suppose when you're paying the amount you pay for the stream (ahem) then you should expect a certain level of service or knowledge from those doing the talking.

The commentators don't seem to get the replays of points/goals/fouls either which I don't think helps them. Even switches before the game they don't know who is or isn't on. Its probably not too difficult to work out really. At the start of the 2nd half yesterday Seamy McCallan said the Bells from Ardboe need to chip in with a few scores and one of them didn't even start.

Don't think that's correct - I heard the bowl Paddy Hunter last night thank Damian O'Hagan for commentating on a key piece of the match as 'I was watching a replay there Damian'

I dunno I have heard a few commentators say about not having a replay of an incident but maybe depends where they are if they have a screen beside them. Though it wouldn't matter how many replays Paddy has sometimes he still wouldn't know whose done what

Thinking back on this is their a possibility he was watching a replay of something else? Coronation Street??

[square_ball]

The commentators don't seem to get the replays of points/goals/fouls either which I don't think helps them. Even switches before the game they don't know who is or isn't on. Its probably not too difficult to work out really. At the start of the 2nd half yesterday Seamy McCallan said the Bells from Ardboe need to chip in with a few scores and one of them didn't even start.

Don't think that's correct - I heard the bowl Paddy Hunter last night thank Damian O'Hagan for commentating on a key piece of the match as 'I was watching a replay there Damian'

I dunno I have heard a few commentators say about not having a replay of an incident but maybe depends where they are if they have a screen beside them. Though it wouldn't matter how many replays Paddy has sometimes he still wouldn't know whose done what

Thinking back on this is their a possibility he was watching a replay of something else? Coronation Street??

Very good