Best way to decide drawn games

[Dougal Maguire]

What about taking 45s out of your hands. Would possibly help improve players ability to score long range points, a skill that sadly appears to be on the wane

[Franko]

Highest points tally or goal tally, which ever one you're trying to promote. Prefer the points tally myself

I like the idea of highest goal tally.

Higher points tally only serves to encourage the scourge on the game that is the mundane fist pass over the bar - a skill which a drunken snake could execute.

[Gael80]

All Ireland series games (QF, SF and Final) should have extra time and then if it's still level a replay. In the replay extra time if required and then next score wins.

[J70]

Penalties or 21 yard frees from halfway out to the sideline.

[seafoid]

Left footed points
Best Panenka
Best rendition of a Marquee in Drumlish
Longest time hanging off crossbar
Cleanest goalie after penos

[Blowitupref]

Penalty shootouts in hockey would probably be better to copy than what we have now.

the attacker gets a chance to run with the ball in a one-on-one situation against the goalkeeper. The attacker starts on the 23-metre line with the ball and the goalkeeper starts on the goal line. When the whistle is blown, both can move and the attacker has 8 seconds to score a goal

[Estimator]

Keep extra time.
With the proviso that the unused subs (including gks) during normal time, have to play all of extra time.
And if the management decide that an unused sub has an "injury" and has to be taken off, then he can't be replaced.

either that, or the county with the best All-Ireland record in Scór is declared the winner.

[Rossfan]

A replay the first option if there is a free weekend.  Could easily have played Armagh v Galway  again this Saturday.

Rules are clear and the same for all so they couldn't play it again next week
Hypothetically where would it be played next weekend??
And the winners out the following weekend again!
Kicking the ball off the ground was a fundamental skill for years till these frees from the hand came in. Now only goalies know how to kick a ball off the ground.
Penalties have existed in Gaelic football since....?

[Captain Obvious]

A replay the first option if there is a free weekend.  Could easily have played Armagh v Galway  again this Saturday.

Rules are clear and the same for all so they couldn't play it again next week
Hypothetically where would it be played next weekend??
And the winners out the following weekend again!
Kicking the ball off the ground was a fundamental skill for years till these frees from the hand came in. Now only goalies know how to kick a ball off the ground.
Penalties have existed in Gaelic football since....?

Penalties to punish fouls not penalty shootout to decide a knock out championship match.

Plenty of provincial grounds could have hosted the replay on Saturday or Sunday.   A week rest so be it however that is on HQ with their congested season and its only going to get worse next year with 4 groups of 4 to find the last 8.

[Rossfan]

"HQ" implementing what Congress voted for.

[lenny]

A replay the first option if there is a free weekend.  Could easily have played Armagh v Galway  again this Saturday.

Rules are clear and the same for all so they couldn't play it again next week
Hypothetically where would it be played next weekend??
And the winners out the following weekend again!
Kicking the ball off the ground was a fundamental skill for years till these frees from the hand came in. Now only goalies know how to kick a ball off the ground.
Penalties have existed in Gaelic football since....?

Penalties to punish fouls not penalty shootout to decide a knock out championship match.

Plenty of provincial grounds could have hosted the replay on Saturday or Sunday.   A week rest so be it however that is on HQ with their congested season and its only going to get worse next year with 4 groups of 4 to find the last 8.

The congested season has been great and penalties are a great way to decide games like yesterday where around 100 minutes have been played. Penalties are a test of nerve and skill. Galway showed great skill and nerve with the quality of their penalties.

[Milltown Row2]

Counting 45's like we do at kids tournaments 

[Armagh18]

What about taking 45s out of your hands. Would possibly help improve players ability to score long range points, a skill that sadly appears to be on the wane

Would be better than penalties for sure. The one v one thing similar to ice hockey or the mls years ago is a novel idea as well. Most goals is another good idea imo would make the game more exciting. Anything but f'ing penalties.

[Captain Obvious]

A replay the first option if there is a free weekend.  Could easily have played Armagh v Galway  again this Saturday.

Rules are clear and the same for all so they couldn't play it again next week
Hypothetically where would it be played next weekend??
And the winners out the following weekend again!
Kicking the ball off the ground was a fundamental skill for years till these frees from the hand came in. Now only goalies know how to kick a ball off the ground.
Penalties have existed in Gaelic football since....?

Penalties to punish fouls not penalty shootout to decide a knock out championship match.

Plenty of provincial grounds could have hosted the replay on Saturday or Sunday.   A week rest so be it however that is on HQ with their congested season and its only going to get worse next year with 4 groups of 4 to find the last 8.

The congested season has been great and penalties are a great way to decide games like yesterday where around 100 minutes have been played. Penalties are a test of nerve and skill. Galway showed great skill and nerve with the quality of their penalties.

In your opinion.

[Look-Up!]

Least amount of hand passes........

Or a big melee at the end