Antrim Hurling

[saffman]

Regards u20 players being unavailable i totally agree.

I believe players develop more playing div 1 than u20 county..

Ive watched u20 boys finish strongly with their club
Looks promising for the following season to push on...
Then they're not seen by their club cause of u20 county, dont properly integrate with the club until post split and almost have to go through the kickstart process again

[Saffron_sam20]

Would that offer Gort na mona a lifeline or would it possibly promote ardoyne?

You'd like to think that the team coming up would get the chance, I know Ardoyne have been pushing the county to let them go up a div. Chatting to a fella plays for them few weeks ago was saying they are going to Limerick for a junior b comp but they dont know who they play yet so they are clearly serious bout pushing on

[Antrim Coaster]

That's a pity as they have been in it for years.

To be honest they haven't progressed much in close to 20 years playing in Antrim.

The season before last they were one point above relegation.

I think its the travelling that would be the issue.

Looks like they are going to play in the Derry league.

[imtommygunn]

I think there may be more midweek travel than there used to be. There was a boy who used to be a very prominent poster who seems to have disappeared now and he was in their setup - he seemed to be indicating that.

It would be tough logistically speaking to get a squad of players to a lot of antrim venues on a weeknight if you're coming from derry.

[SaffronSports]

Dungannon didn't play in Antrim this year did they?

[NorthAntrim]

Would that offer Gort na mona a lifeline or would it possibly promote ardoyne?

You'd like to think that the team coming up would get the chance, I know Ardoyne have been pushing the county to let them go up a div. Chatting to a fella plays for them few weeks ago was saying they are going to Limerick for a junior b comp but they dont know who they play yet so they are clearly serious bout pushing on

AFAIK antrim teams travel to this every year

[Milltown Row2]

Would that offer Gort na mona a lifeline or would it possibly promote ardoyne?

You'd like to think that the team coming up would get the chance, I know Ardoyne have been pushing the county to let them go up a div. Chatting to a fella plays for them few weeks ago was saying they are going to Limerick for a junior b comp but they dont know who they play yet so they are clearly serious bout pushing on

AFAIK antrim teams travel to this every year

Held on the day and a great incentive for clubs at junior b level

[NorthAntrim]

I think there may be more midweek travel than there used to be. There was a boy who used to be a very prominent poster who seems to have disappeared now and he was in their setup - he seemed to be indicating that.

It would be tough logistically speaking to get a squad of players to a lot of antrim venues on a weeknight if you're coming from derry.

I'm sure it's handy sorted refixing games to a weekend especially versus hurling only clubs though. Good road to travel now too

[NorthAntrim]

That's a pity as they have been in it for years.

To be honest they haven't progressed much in close to 20 years playing in Antrim.

The season before last they were one point above relegation.

I think its the travelling that would be the issue.

Looks like they are going to play in the Derry league.

Well if they do opt out and it doesn't work I wouldn't like to think they'd jump back into division 3 the following season

[johnnycool]

Well will Cushendall keep it pucked out to Slaughtneil or did they get the dirty diesel out of their system yesterday?

If Slaughtneil have maintained the same standards as last year then they'd go in as slight favourites IMO.

[imtommygunn]

I don't see Cushendall beating Slaughtneil tbh. I do hope I am wrong. Cushendall have a physicality which is much better than a lot of teams in antrim but that won't be the same against Slaughtneil. It depends on how McManus is handled by Slaughneil I guess and then what Cushendall do with Rodgers. I think Cushendall have better defenders than anyone in ulster to handle Rodgers but there's a few other boys in there too and I am not convinced they have enough of a spread in the forwards. Again hope I am wrong.

[johnnycool]

I don't see Cushendall beating Slaughtneil tbh. I do hope I am wrong. Cushendall have a physicality which is much better than a lot of teams in antrim but that won't be the same against Slaughtneil. It depends on how McManus is handled by Slaughneil I guess and then what Cushendall do with Rodgers. I think Cushendall have better defenders than anyone in ulster to handle Rodgers but there's a few other boys in there too and I am not convinced they have enough of a spread in the forwards. Again hope I am wrong.

I'd let Eoghan Campbell do a job on Rodgers, serious defender is Campbell, take Rodgers out and you seriously blunt Slaughtneil but they do have others.
If Rodgers starts to have a big impact in the game he'll not only bother the scoreboard but is good at bringing his teammates into the game as well.

McManus is going to be in for some serious treatment at the other end though, it won't be the kid gloves stuff Tom Murray was at yesterday either.

[imtommygunn]

I don't think Campbell is a great man marker though - better ball playing CHB. I would suspect you'll see a Burke on Rodgers though which one would be the question.

Yeah McManus will get it tougher in this game. Be interesting to see who he's up against. I doubt McLaughlin will have seen close marking like it either.

[SaffronSports]

I'd put Paddy Burke on Rodgers. Campbell got it tight against James McNaughton in the county final so I'd probably prefer to try something else. Either way though you're losing a bit going the other way by having one of them doing a man marking job.

[Oso]

I can't see Cushendall beating Slaughtneil.  All yesterday proved is just how reliant Cushendall are on McManus.  He's a class act but he's lost more than a yard of pace these days (no shame) and Portaferry were dire at trying to curtail him.   

He had a poor enough county final but is still a threat from placed balls and there's no way he'll be afforded the same space and lack of physicality he enjoyed yesterday.  I think SN will win comfortably enough but McManus's placed balls will keep Cushendall in it for a while.

I don't see the point of playing Christy McNaughton, he doesn't have the mobility anymore and is too easy to play against. Some of those subs that came on for Cushendall yesterday must be scratching their head at that one and would threaten more with pace and running and mobility.