Berbatov stays

[DUBSFORSAM1]

Benni McCarthy has been far better

How do you work that one out???

[gallsman]

Perhaps by scoring more league goals with inferior supporting players...?!?!

Just a thought...

[tyroneboi]

Berbatov has had a bigger impact though plus he is younger so will be making an impact for longer than McCarthy. McCarthy is a class player as well though but i think that Berbatov just edges it!!

[oakleaf stateside]

Benni McCarthy has been far better

How do you work that one out???

mccarthy only can score he is not a play maker

[STREET FIGHTER]

Benni McCarthy has been far better

How do you work that one out???

Because he cost a 3rd of the money and scored more goals.

And he's only a year or so older than Berb

[tyroneboi]

Try 4 years older - McCarthy is almost 30, Berbatov has just turned 26 so arguably just about reaching his peak!

[DUBSFORSAM1]

Benni McCarthy has been far better

How do you work that one out???

Because he cost a 3rd of the money and scored more goals.

And he's only a year or so older than Berb

Cost doesn't come into whether a player is better or not...

Berbatov scored 5 less premiership goals - but still scored more over the season....(also 4 of McCarthy's goals were penalties which Berbatov doesn't take)...
Berbatov had 10 assists while McCarthy had none....so in terms of goals scored due to Berbatov he is comfortably ahead...