All Ireland club football championships 2023/24

[seafoid]

None of this would of happened if subs weren't  allowed on just to waste time. The ref could have stopped subs coming on. Cynicism rewarded.Glen should appeal to make the point but decline offer of replay

If there is an appeal the rules kick in. It's not a matter of opinion. It's not how anyone in the GAA feels. The game is played with 15 players.
The ref's decision on a game cannot be challenged but this is different. It's about the DNA of the game.

[seafoid]

They should do it for Watty. He stood up against injustice.
I hope they hammer Kilmacud in the replay. They wouldvneed a big shift from the forwards.

https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2023/0123/1350410-kelly-gaa-should-order-replay-not-put-onus-on-glen/

[johnnycool]

They should do it for Watty. He stood up against injustice.
I hope they hammer Kilmacud in the replay. They wouldvneed a big shift from the forwards.

https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2023/0123/1350410-kelly-gaa-should-order-replay-not-put-onus-on-glen/

Are you Galway lads sore with Walsh? 

[bennydorano]

Hopefully opinion isn't split in Glen whatever they decide, could be like contentious family money in a will, create nothing but ill feeling that is hard to repair and do damage long term. HQ really should be making the decision without putting the pressure on Glen to be the bad guys.

[Armagh18]

Agree with Brolly. Decision should have been made on Sunday evening though.

[thewobbler]

Hopefully opinion isn't split in Glen whatever they decide, could be like contentious family money in a will, create nothing but ill feeling that is hard to repair and do damage long term. HQ really should be making the decision without putting the pressure on Glen to be the bad guys.

HQ made a decision; that they weren't going to intervene without an objection.

It's on Glen to decide.

It's not a difficult decision FfS. Just send the letter Glen and stop pontificating on Twitter.

[WT4E]

A good point made earlier by someone here I hadn't thought about.

Glen send the email and put it back in GAA hands and sure then decide if you want to take part in a replay if it is offered.

[magpie seanie]

People need to understand how the GAA disciplinary system works. The media are consistently bad in this regard.

Also - read the rule and try to understand it. If this gets pushed the logical penalty is a small fine (read the rule before you come at me). There are options for penalties presented in the rule from severe (award/forfeiture) to moderate (replay) to light (fine). In the range of possible breaches of this rule ask yourself truthfully - what category does it fall into? About 10 seconds of playing time where the ball doesn't come near the play?

[Franko]

Glen chairman phones relevant GAA mandarin and says - "We're going to appeal, award us a replay and we'll decline it.  BUT, we need something for it."

GAA award replay

Glen decline

Both respective organisations look good in the public eye

Glen get a big cheque.


This is how it should play out if anyone had any sense.

[thewobbler]

Glen chairman phones relevant GAA mandarin and says - "We're going to appeal, award us a replay and we'll decline it.  BUT, we need something for it."

GAA award replay

Glen decline

Both respective organisations look good in the public eye

Glen get a big cheque.


This is how it should play out if anyone had any sense.

Big cheque, huh?

Not really what the association is about, but whatever floats your boat I suppose.

[Milltown Row2]

People need to understand how the GAA disciplinary system works. The media are consistently bad in this regard.

Also - read the rule and try to understand it. If this gets pushed the logical penalty is a small fine (read the rule before you come at me). There are options for penalties presented in the rule from severe (award/forfeiture) to moderate (replay) to light (fine). In the range of possible breaches of this rule ask yourself truthfully - what category does it fall into? About 10 seconds of playing time where the ball doesn't come near the play?

It was a f**k up and someone has to take the blame for this, not Glen, I said had there been another 5 minutes Glen would have still struggled to win the game, the one Glass missed summed up some of their play in that second half in front of goal, it wasn't to be. Personally if it had have been a one point difference and this lad prevented Glen from scoring a nailed on point, then yes, I could 100% stand over their right to have a replay. But the reality is slightly different and looking at those penalties available to Croke Park, they will take the fine one and move on

[Armagh18]

People need to understand how the GAA disciplinary system works. The media are consistently bad in this regard.

Also - read the rule and try to understand it. If this gets pushed the logical penalty is a small fine (read the rule before you come at me). There are options for penalties presented in the rule from severe (award/forfeiture) to moderate (replay) to light (fine). In the range of possible breaches of this rule ask yourself truthfully - what category does it fall into? About 10 seconds of playing time where the ball doesn't come near the play?

Listen to Brolly on otb. Should be a fine for the Mannion breach as it's immaterial but the other fella was in the thick of it.

[Ghost]

If the game was to be replayed its bound to be difficult for both sets of players to get themselves geared up for it. Bound to be a strange atmosphere amongst the crowd also.

It's almost a lose lose for glen, if they're beat again, was it really worth all the bother for more heartbreak and if they win there is bound to be some sort of feeling that its a hollow victory in some ways.

Tricky situation for them whatever way you look at. Maybe the suggestion of a payout from the GAA like a players holiday wwould be the best option.

[Truth hurts]

send the email and replay the game

[seafoid]

If the game was to be replayed its bound to be difficult for both sets of players to get themselves geared up for it. Bound to be a strange atmosphere amongst the crowd also.

It's almost a lose lose for glen, if they're beat again, was it really worth all the bother for more heartbreak and if they win there is bound to be some sort of feeling that its a hollow victory in some ways.

Tricky situation for them whatever way you look at. Maybe the suggestion of a payout from the GAA like a players holiday wwould be the best option.

It happened in a hurling semi final in 1998. The ref blew up 3 minutes early . Clare were leading. Offaly objected and there was a sit down on the pitch.
Offaly won the replay.