Tyrone Club Football and Hurling

Started by Gabriel_Hurl, November 09, 2006, 10:54:03 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

The_Slug


Quote from: Serial Mark Taker on October 06, 2024, 11:10:26 PM
Quote from: Carmen1932 on October 06, 2024, 11:03:39 PM
Quote from: OpenYourEyesRef on October 06, 2024, 08:28:10 PM
Quote from: Serial Mark Taker on October 06, 2024, 08:20:05 PMWhat has that Ref seen there to gift that penalty an absolute joke what a clown

Campbell is historically poor and listens to the crowd more so than trusting his gut, Errigal very nearly robbed for a replay there based on his decision

Oisin McCann fouled for the first penalty. Nathan Donnelly also fouled for the second. Had the jersey near pulled off him. Both decisions correct.

Good luck to Errigal in Ulster. And good luck to Donaghmore for the All-Ireland Club title by 2030.

You obviously weren't watching the same game as the rest of us was no foul for the second penalty. The state of officiating in Tyrone is brutal and that sums it up on one of the biggest games of the year. I repeat what a clown

McGinley had a serious grip of Nathan Donnelly's jersey. Ref did blow a bit late for it, which is probably where the confusion came from. But don't let that get in the way of your tirade on all officials

Moonshine

Quote from: Carmen1932 on October 06, 2024, 11:03:39 PM
Quote from: OpenYourEyesRef on October 06, 2024, 08:28:10 PM
Quote from: Serial Mark Taker on October 06, 2024, 08:20:05 PMWhat has that Ref seen there to gift that penalty an absolute joke what a clown

Campbell is historically poor and listens to the crowd more so than trusting his gut, Errigal very nearly robbed for a replay there based on his decision

Oisin McCann fouled for the first penalty. Nathan Donnelly also fouled for the second. Had the jersey near pulled off him. Both decisions correct.

Good luck to Errigal in Ulster. And good luck to Donaghmore for the All-Ireland Club title by 2030.

19 years and counting

OpenYourEyesRef

Quote from: The_Slug on October 06, 2024, 11:33:27 PM
Quote from: Serial Mark Taker on October 06, 2024, 11:10:26 PM
Quote from: Carmen1932 on October 06, 2024, 11:03:39 PM
Quote from: OpenYourEyesRef on October 06, 2024, 08:28:10 PM
Quote from: Serial Mark Taker on October 06, 2024, 08:20:05 PMWhat has that Ref seen there to gift that penalty an absolute joke what a clown

Campbell is historically poor and listens to the crowd more so than trusting his gut, Errigal very nearly robbed for a replay there based on his decision

Oisin McCann fouled for the first penalty. Nathan Donnelly also fouled for the second. Had the jersey near pulled off him. Both decisions correct.

Good luck to Errigal in Ulster. And good luck to Donaghmore for the All-Ireland Club title by 2030.

You obviously weren't watching the same game as the rest of us was no foul for the second penalty. The state of officiating in Tyrone is brutal and that sums it up on one of the biggest games of the year. I repeat what a clown

McGinley had a serious grip of Nathan Donnelly's jersey. Ref did blow a bit late for it, which is probably where the confusion came from. But don't let that get in the way of your tirade on all officials

All good watching it in slow motion on the TV afterwards, It was trivial compared to some of the things can happen under a high ball coming in.

The confusion was because anyone that watched it in real time seen very little at play to warrant a penalty in a Championship game

thebigfullforward

Quote from: OpenYourEyesRef on October 07, 2024, 07:16:10 AM
Quote from: The_Slug on October 06, 2024, 11:33:27 PM
Quote from: Serial Mark Taker on October 06, 2024, 11:10:26 PM
Quote from: Carmen1932 on October 06, 2024, 11:03:39 PM
Quote from: OpenYourEyesRef on October 06, 2024, 08:28:10 PM
Quote from: Serial Mark Taker on October 06, 2024, 08:20:05 PMWhat has that Ref seen there to gift that penalty an absolute joke what a clown

Campbell is historically poor and listens to the crowd more so than trusting his gut, Errigal very nearly robbed for a replay there based on his decision

Oisin McCann fouled for the first penalty. Nathan Donnelly also fouled for the second. Had the jersey near pulled off him. Both decisions correct.

Good luck to Errigal in Ulster. And good luck to Donaghmore for the All-Ireland Club title by 2030.

You obviously weren't watching the same game as the rest of us was no foul for the second penalty. The state of officiating in Tyrone is brutal and that sums it up on one of the biggest games of the year. I repeat what a clown

McGinley had a serious grip of Nathan Donnelly's jersey. Ref did blow a bit late for it, which is probably where the confusion came from. But don't let that get in the way of your tirade on all officials

All good watching it in slow motion on the TV afterwards, It was trivial compared to some of the things can happen under a high ball coming in.

The confusion was because anyone that watched it in real time seen very little at play to warrant a penalty in a Championship game
Sitting near KC ones and they didn't understand what it was given for either. Few other decisions I thought weren't made like Colhoun getting the elbow to the face and KC got possession and got a shot away only for him to go back and give the KC player a yellow for the elbow. Surely if you're giving the yellow you'd give the free as well? Few Errigal ones dragged down when running through on goal and no cards shown. Will say though I thought we got some handy frees too. Don't think we got them as handy as KC but maybe got them at more important times in the game

square_ball

Niall Kelly lucky to avoid a black for taking Bradley out before the 1st penalty was awarded when Bradley went for a give and go. I'll give the ref the benefit of the doubt for the 2nd penalty as the TV camera showed behind the incident for the shirt pull.

Goals_Will_Come

Quote from: scout on October 06, 2024, 11:14:17 PMAfter watching most of the club championship this year & football in general. We're in desperate need of a revamp. Every game is a mixture of rugby & basketball, all men behind the ball, keep the ball back & sideways and basically 1 or 2 players that can break the line and score or win a free.

Every game is a carbon copy of the other & every team has the exact same tactics.

You get a good game now about 1 every 10 if lucky.


Yes, weather was terrible Saturday, but anyone who persisted through the 2 intermediate games deserve a medal.
Weather is definitely a big factor in them games. Why the games weren't played in Dungannon is very strange. In terms of overall quality of games, my opinion is how the teams play it. If you play 15 behind the ball or rock up man to man if you don't go out and play with some pace and intensity it won't matter what setup or tactics you come with. The best games tend to be the ones where the teams both bring that pace and intensity. There are to many teams now copying tactics of county teams but playing at too slow a pace with pedestrian build up and then leads to these games were chances and scores are at a premium.

Patsypower

Oguz and Ben McDonnell have a neck for completely disappearing on the field, granted Ben moreso than Joe. No wonder their kickouts take so long their keeper cannot find them. Yes errigals half backs do have a lot to offer but it's Colhoun that does the majority of it hes a complete workhorse. McCartan goes to wherever McDonnell goes. Their half forwards though, that's different, mcginley and mcgirr weaken the team.
if Darragh canavan isn't fit errigal are in bother, he's obviously irreplaceable but who do errigal really have could make an impact in thr full forward line. Thomas canavan slows the game for too much, kavanagh is no longer at that standard and traynor hasn't got the shooting power.

WT4E

Thought the commentary was poor last night to be honest. For such an exciting climax I don't think the commentary matched the conclusion IMO.

The use of Garryowen continues - Even using it when McGirr hit a brilliant point.
Not sure who was on co commentary but they did a decent job of keeping us up to date with who the players where.

square_ball

Quote from: WT4E on October 07, 2024, 12:50:50 PMThought the commentary was poor last night to be honest. For such an exciting climax I don't think the commentary matched the conclusion IMO.

The use of Garryowen continues - Even using it when McGirr hit a brilliant point.
Not sure who was on co commentary but they did a decent job of keeping us up to date with who the players where.

Ronan O'Neill was with Paddy last night and I thought he was very good. Diarmuid McNulty is good as well on co-commentary.

Batman12345

Quote from: Batman12345 on October 02, 2024, 10:55:36 PMTrillick v Dungannon

 Very tight game. Feel it will be nip and tuck, but Trillick to maintain control in the last 5 minutes and see out the game.

Errigal v Killyclogher

Errigal to get a few soft frees towards the end and win by one or two. However if Bradley is on form he could be hard stopped, been player of the championship so far.

Moortown v Derrylaughan

will be a slug fest, expect hard hits and a lack of quality. Think Derrylaughan will get over the line, hearing reports that the vibes in the moortown camp have taken a hit in the last few weeks.

Moy v Greencastle

Difference will be Conroy and the experience of the Cavnaghs. Moy by 3.


Nearly spot on. If the ref wasn't playing for the draw in the moy game predictions would've been correct. Obvious the refs have been told to play for the draw. Disgusting.

Truthsayer

Quote from: Batman12345 on October 07, 2024, 05:48:57 PM
Quote from: Batman12345 on October 02, 2024, 10:55:36 PMTrillick v Dungannon

 Very tight game. Feel it will be nip and tuck, but Trillick to maintain control in the last 5 minutes and see out the game.

Errigal v Killyclogher

Errigal to get a few soft frees towards the end and win by one or two. However if Bradley is on form he could be hard stopped, been player of the championship so far.

Moortown v Derrylaughan

will be a slug fest, expect hard hits and a lack of quality. Think Derrylaughan will get over the line, hearing reports that the vibes in the moortown camp have taken a hit in the last few weeks.

Moy v Greencastle

Difference will be Conroy and the experience of the Cavnaghs. Moy by 3.


Nearly spot on. If the ref wasn't playing for the draw in the moy game predictions would've been correct. Obvious the refs have been told to play for the draw. Disgusting.
Tell the bookie you were nearly right! 😆

Carmen1932

Quote from: Serial Mark Taker on October 07, 2024, 04:44:49 PM
Quote from: square_ball on October 07, 2024, 12:52:52 PM
Quote from: WT4E on October 07, 2024, 12:50:50 PMThought the commentary was poor last night to be honest. For such an exciting climax I don't think the commentary matched the conclusion IMO.

The use of Garryowen continues - Even using it when McGirr hit a brilliant point.
Not sure who was on co commentary but they did a decent job of keeping us up to date with who the players where.

Ronan O'Neill was with Paddy last night and I thought he was very good. Diarmuid McNulty is good as well on co-commentary.

The guest commentators are usually pretty good it's the main boys are woeful Paddy Hunter can't even name the correct players when he has a sheet in-front of his eyes he'd be totally lost if someone wasn't beside him who actually knows a bit about the game

Who appointed Paddy Hunter to be the TyroneTV commentator? I know they both have pony tails but he couldn't tell the difference between M. Flanagan and C. McCann last night. Also said Peter Canavan instead of Peter Harte. Constantly messing up throughout- makes the whole thing look very unprofessional.

Carmen1932

#49812
Quote from: Patsypower on October 07, 2024, 12:38:54 PMOguz and Ben McDonnell have a neck for completely disappearing on the field, granted Ben moreso than Joe. No wonder their kickouts take so long their keeper cannot find them. Yes errigals half backs do have a lot to offer but it's Colhoun that does the majority of it hes a complete workhorse. McCartan goes to wherever McDonnell goes. Their half forwards though, that's different, mcginley and mcgirr weaken the team.
if Darragh canavan isn't fit errigal are in bother, he's obviously irreplaceable but who do errigal really have could make an impact in thr full forward line. Thomas canavan slows the game for too much, kavanagh is no longer at that standard and traynor hasn't got the shooting power.

Wouldn't rubbish Mark Kavanagh that quickly. As a Carmen man, I think he is a class act. Worth far more than the 2 injury time minutes he got last night. Would start for almost any other club in the county. Personally, I would start him for Errigal.

clarshack

Quote from: Carmen1932 on October 07, 2024, 09:49:48 PM
Quote from: Serial Mark Taker on October 07, 2024, 04:44:49 PM
Quote from: square_ball on October 07, 2024, 12:52:52 PM
Quote from: WT4E on October 07, 2024, 12:50:50 PMThought the commentary was poor last night to be honest. For such an exciting climax I don't think the commentary matched the conclusion IMO.

The use of Garryowen continues - Even using it when McGirr hit a brilliant point.
Not sure who was on co commentary but they did a decent job of keeping us up to date with who the players where.

Ronan O'Neill was with Paddy last night and I thought he was very good. Diarmuid McNulty is good as well on co-commentary.

The guest commentators are usually pretty good it's the main boys are woeful Paddy Hunter can't even name the correct players when he has a sheet in-front of his eyes he'd be totally lost if someone wasn't beside him who actually knows a bit about the game

Who appointed Paddy Hunter to be the TyroneTV commentator? I know they both have pony tails but he couldn't tell the difference between M. Flanagan and C. McCann last night. Also said Peter Canavan instead of Peter Harte. Constantly messing up throughout- makes the whole thing look very unprofessional.

When RTE commentators regularly get things wrong in the big county games, you can expect Tyrone TV commentators to get some things wrong too. It's no big deal imo and if you don't like any of the commentators turn the volume down.

WT4E

Jet and Damian Harvey are better IMO. They make some mistakes here and there like all commentators but what I like is they commentate to the excitement of the game which always adds to the stream. Maybe I am on my own but just thought with the exciting finish to Sunday nights match the commentary didn't match it.