The Sunday Game

[BennyCake]

Exactly rather than telling us X passed the ball to Y and over the bar.
We've already seen that ourselves.

And it's 8 points each, 25 minutes gone, and it's been level 5 times. And that's his 3 point of the game. Oh Christ...

[From the Bunker]

A lot blaming the referee today! Jez, there was so many borderline hits and a huge intensity there. One middle aged man to keep an eye on everything is too much. Both of Tipp disallowed goals in the first half were good calls. It's not the referee's fault that Hawk eye was so slow to make a decision. And what was the referee to do? The Red was correct also.

[armaghniac]

Why is Hawkeye slow, it being a computer? Does someone review it?

[From the Bunker]

Why is Hawkeye slow, it being a computer? Does someone review it?

In real time i suppose the boys in the Hawk eye box were caught out by the incident in real time. They had to review it, make a decision and tell the referee. 30 seconds in such a situation is not much time.

[ardtole]

A lot blaming the referee today! Jez, there was so many borderline hits and a huge intensity there. One middle aged man to keep an eye on everything is too much. Both of Tipp disallowed goals in the first half were good calls. It's not the referee's fault that Hawk eye was so slow to make a decision. And what was the referee to do? The Red was correct also.

I thought the first tipp goal should have stood. All the other decisions, although marginal were correct calls. Very tough game to referee today, and I thought a lot if the calls,  he was damned if he did and damned if he didn't. Incredible game though.

[ardtole]

B
Why is Hawkeye slow, it being a computer? Does someone review it?

In real time i suppose the boys in the Hawk eye box were caught out by the incident in real time. They had to review it, make a decision and tell the referee. 30 seconds in such a situation is not much time.

By the time the keeper caught the sliothar, cleared his lines, ball was moved into the ff line and goal, was probably under 10-15 seconds, impossible to communicate to ref In that short period of time

[Maiden1]

B
Why is Hawkeye slow, it being a computer? Does someone review it?

In real time i suppose the boys in the Hawk eye box were caught out by the incident in real time. They had to review it, make a decision and tell the referee. 30 seconds in such a situation is not much time.

By the time the keeper caught the sliothar, cleared his lines, ball was moved into the ff line and goal, was probably under 10-15 seconds, impossible to communicate to ref In that short period of time

In NBA if ref calls 3 points and video review says 2 they just play on and correct the score. Maybe in last minute stop the game and wait on the review as it might affect if team goes for point or not.

[Tubberman]

in the replay, looked like wexford player threw himself to.rhe ground rather than tipp man dragging him  down, but his arms were definitely arouns him, so could easily have been given

[didlyi]

Why is Hawkeye slow, it being a computer? Does someone review it?

TBF the incident today was the first of its kind. Hawkeye is usually to determine a wide or a point. In this case I was shocked to see it also works on another dimension. Well done Hawkeye I say.

[Walt Jabsco]

Hawkeye Protocols for use where Score Detection System is installed

The Hawkeye Point Detection System is available for matches played in Croke Park and Semple Stadium. The Referee or an
umpire can initiate the Hawkeye Review for any close calls where there is an element of doubt.
In the case of an umpire initiating the process, the umpire will call for the review process by signalling a square in the air
towards the Referee. The Referee will do the same. The Hawkeye Review Official acknowledges that the review is underway
and output is then to the Big Screen and directly to the Referee from the Review Official.
Where the Referee and Umpires have made an error the Hawkeye Review Official will interrupt, ask the Referee to stop play
and initiate a Hawkeye Review.
The flow chart below best describes the process:
HAWKEYE PROTOCOL
Point scoring attempt
No Doubt
Hawkeye
Conclusive
Referee
decision
Referee
decision
Hawkeye
Conclusive
Hawkeye
Inconclusive
Hawkeye
Inconclusive
Umpire Doubt Referee Doubt
Umpire signals decision Umpire "calls" for Hawkeye
Umpire signals
decision
Umpire signals
decision
Referee
consults with
umpires
Referee
consults with
umpires
Referee "calls" for Hawkeye
Umpire signals
decision
Umpire signals
decision
Following Review the game restarts with a
kick/puck out or 45 (Football)/65 (Hurling), as normal.

[Milltown Row2]

Was told Hawkeye was the boss and that was it. Their decision is correct, whether Sheedy thought it was over or not, it wasn't. Catch over the bar was a point. Hawkeye did it's job

[BennyCake]

At 1-16 each, definite Wexford penalty

[Tony Baloney]

Donal Og was a breath of fresh air when started years ago. Can't listen to him now.

[MayoBuck]

Why is Hawkeye slow, it being a computer? Does someone review it?

It's not instant like the goal line technology in soccer these days. There are several cameras around Croke Park and they all work in tandem to make the decision.

[BennyCake]

Donal Og was a breath of fresh air when started years ago. Can't listen to him now.

Even Big Jack and the Brits got a touch tonight!